prune or not prune
phatboyrose
9 years ago
Featured Answer
Comments (16)
digdirt2
9 years agophatboyrose
9 years agoRelated Discussions
comparing pruned and not pruned tomato production?
Comments (12)lonmower - Like you I'm in a cool summer climate. We're in a clearing in the woods in western WA, so a bit cooler yet. Once the sun lowers in mid August we get even more dappled shade for part of the day from the tall trees. I have pruned before thinking it was the right thing to do. It wasn't worth the time or lower harvest plus when there is a hot spell you get sunscald like was said. I have pretty good air circulation, so that's not been a problem even with an intensively planted row. You could try pruning one plant & see what you notice. I either pruned or not, so can't really compare one plant to another. I just prefer to let the tomatoes grow like crazy in June hopefully blossoming & setting fruit into July. My goal is 5 trusses of fruit per plant. If I pruned them I would be removing chances of fruit. In a long season climate you could prune and still get a good harvest. I know my 5 trusses is meager, but a reasonable goal for my short season. I plant more plants to try to make up the difference and count every vine ripened tomato a blessing. I encourage the tomatoes to ripen by stopping watering in August & only water if plants wilt. I have lots of organic matter in my soil + mulch + soakers to water. Around Labor Day if not right before I cut any blossoms & small fruits. Once temps are below 50 degrees again I bring in all fruits to ripen inside because when it's cold like that they lose flavor and just rot. Below 50 degrees the garden becomes a refrigerator, which is good for fall & winter harvesting of cool weather vegetables, but not warm weather ones. Others in my area can keep them producing until frost especially with some protection after that 1st early light frost in October....See MorePruning question - pruning young small roses?
Comments (5)I've had the most success with propogation when I did it during the summer months. Don't know why, but it's something I've seen over and over. I've also never never ever lost a rose of any size when I pruned it after April when it was actively growing and all cool nights are over. I have lost roses from my early spring pruning, or even (trying to learn from that lesson) pruning around the time of the first flush. Again, I don't know why, I just know that I've killed a lot of roses through spring pruning. That being said, I wouldn't prune any small roses except for the reason you've listed: propogation....See MoreWhat height to prune, if I prune?
Comments (4)I don't prune, but if I were to, I would not take off any suckers until the plant is planted in it's final growing place, whether that be in the ground or a large pot. I would wait until the transplanted disturbed roots were established and the plant showed signs of healthy new growth. My feeling is that it's beneficial to keep all the above ground leaves to channel energy down to the roots until they become well established. But tomatoes are quite forgiving of all kinds of treatment, so in the long run (barring disease) they tend to survive and thrive no matter what you do to them....See MoreFiddle Leaf Fig Root Prune -- top pruning necessary?
Comments (5)Thanks and appreciation for the kind words, IP! If I must prune or defoliate, my instinct, given that days are shortening rather than lengthening, is to remove some of the bottom leaves first--does this seem reasonable? A couple of notes so you can tell where I'm coming from:Every leaf is an individual food factory in which the plant's true food (simple sugar) is synthesized during photosynthesis. Your plant is very apically dominant, which means it's genetically programmed to spend about 2/3 of the food/energy it creates in the top 1/3 of the tree; so, the top grows quite fast compared to the lower leaves and branches. Leaves and branches along the lower part of the trunk contribute significantly to the strength/ thickness of the lower trunk. This helps to make the trunk strong enough to resist laying over (bending - so it needs staking). Shortening the trunk has the same effect as shortening a stick that when long, bends easily. When shortened, it's much more difficult to bend. So, if you have to prune, the top is the place to do it. The good news is, if it isn't wilting in the day or two after repotting, you're not likely to encounter issues. I don't wonder if more photosynthetic activity might support faster recovery, especially given the season, since I can water every day if I need to, so access to water isn't as limiting as root mass to absorb it. I don't have much personal experience root pruning/recovering, really appreciate any guidance on the balance. If you don't see any wilting within 48 hours, you can move it back to where it was. It's good that you understand the balancing of the root to shoot ratio. The balancing is going to be done no matter what - whether you do it or the plant. In cases where the rootwork was more severe than what it sound like you did, it's better if the grower decides what leaves and/or branches will be shed, as some branches are often much more important to the o/a composition. A grow medium about as damp as a well wrung out sponge is best for water uptake, so please don't think you can force more water uptake by keeping the medium wetter. Does the 2-leaf suggestion apply equally to lyrata as other smaller-leaf ficus? Yes I haven't seen any pictures of lyrata with heavily branched canopy, it seems a little tight in my mind--a 12 branch indoor lyrata sounds neat but I can't visualize it.Try this link. I wish the top wasn't floppy, I figure it's a mix of new growth + height + lack of mechanical stimulation to thicken. Very good observations! I do not wish to stake this tree and hope that shaking it vigorously a few times a week after the roots set will help thicken the stem. You can flex the stemwhenever you think about it to stimulate lignin production. Lignin makes wood woody and strong. Or, you can brush the stem with a stiff brush regularly, which stimulates formation of ethylene (a growth regulator/ hormone) which stimulates thickening of the stem. I understand some ficus are hemiepiphytic and appreciate support but I'd rather to encourage a thicker stem--I have a couple smaller ficus I'd like to train straight+thick while small too. Certainly pruning off the floppy top would solve this problem; if there are other techniques I'm very interested! Under low light conditions, pruning back at regular intervals is the best way to ensure a self-supporting trunk that won't lay over. Thickening of the trunk, at any given point along the trunk, is the product of what is growing above that point. The more leaves and branches you have on the entire tree, the faster the trunk will thicken. If it doesn't thicken fast enough to be self-supporting, the top gets pruned back and regrown ...... because the top of the tree is going to get 2/3 of the tree's energy w/o you having to do anything other than restrain it (the top) if it is in full outdoor sun. If you don't restrain it, you'll start to lose lower branches and interior foliage due to A) lack of light/ the top hogging the lion's share of the energy - something to think about later. The tree with the big white scar was about 9' tall when chopped back. Same tree 3 years later ^^^ Last summer ^^^^ Of course that chop was made for a different reason, to produce a rapidly tapering trunk. Your pruning wouldn't be even close to that severe. BTW - if you're pleased with a straight trunk and no branching, you can achieve that end, even after shortening the trunk. It seems like maybe a bit before June would also be the best time for this so the new buds grow in tightly, right? I can easily visualize training the benjamina into many many tight branches, I'm really looking forward to learning from the plant on this rehab project. Yes, June would be the best time to hard prune it, though it wouldn't hurt to remove some of the unnecessary branches now. Your tree is a Ficus microcarpa and it's leaves are a bit thicker and more 'leathery' than benjamina. It's a good tree to learn on because it's a strong back-budder when healthy. Another microcarpa: Pruned very hard in June ^^^ Early to mid-August (6-8 wks later) Pruned again and wired, same day. How do you deal with all the extra flush water after watering? All plants are outdoors in summer, so no problem. In winter, I raise the plants above their collection saucers so the effluent has no pathway back into the grow medium. I allow the water to remain in the saucer where it evaporates and reduces the amount of energy it takes to keep humidity in the grow area up around 55%. For most collection saucers I use sturdy but disposable plastic dinner plates. Fortunately, all my plants are in the basement under lights, so I don't have any concern about how tacky the collection 'saucers' would look in the living areas of our home. You might be able to make a simple device that allows you to use any vacuum cleaner to such water from the collection saucers. It would require a large jar with 1 long flexible tube through the top but extending into the jar for an inch or more. Another tube/hose would be fitted so one end goes barely through the top of the jar, the other end being connected to your vacuum. When suction is applied, water would run through your collection hose, drop into the bottom of the jar where it could not be sucked into the tube connected to the vacuum. Al...See Moreseysonn
9 years agodigdirt2
9 years agoseysonn
9 years agomacers
9 years agodigdirt2
9 years agoChippah
6 years agoChippah
6 years agorgreen48
6 years agoSeysonn_ 8a-NC/HZ-7
6 years agodigdirt2
6 years agoncrealestateguy
6 years agodaleyc
6 years agodigdirt2
6 years ago
Related Stories
WINTER GARDENINGPruning Secrets for Exquisite Roses
Encourage gorgeous blooms year after year with this time-tested advice on how to prune your rosebush in winter for health and shape
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESHow to Prune Your Flowering Shrubs for the Best Blooms
Less is often more when it comes to properly pruning flowering shrubs. Here’s what to do and why
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESGot Frost-Damaged Plants? How It Happens, and When and How to Prune
Crispy brown leaves are a sure sign that Jack Frost has been to your neighborhood
Full StoryWINTER GARDENINGCalifornia Gardener's January Checklist
Winter-defying blooms and pruning saws earn a cheer, while California-focused gardening design books get a well-deserved shout-out
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESSouthwest Gardener's March Checklist
Dust off your gardening tools and get busy pruning to help your trees and plants reach their full potential
Full StorySOUTHWEST GARDENINGSouthwest Gardener's May Checklist
Let May's warm temperatures guide your edible and flowering garden plantings, and don't forget to protect and prune your picks
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESSouthwest Gardener's July Checklist
Hold on to your hat and prune those tree branches; monsoon season means damage prevention is key
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESPacific Northwest Gardener: What to Do in June
Now's the time to prune pines and vines, prevent pests and buy June-blooming plants to keep your garden healthy and beautiful
Full StoryMOST POPULAREnjoy Your Summer Garden — Here’s What to Do in July
Our July gardening guides take the guesswork out of summer watering, pruning and planting. See our tips for your U.S. region
Full StoryNORTHWEST GARDENINGPacific Northwest Gardener's January Checklist
Planning, pruning and planting now will help your garden flourish in the coming year
Full Story
digdirt2