Best Birch for Northwest? Other tree options?
fragaria
16 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (11)
mkirkwag
16 years agoEmbothrium
16 years agoRelated Discussions
What Paw Paw varieties are best for pacific northwest?
Comments (10)This is a follow up. The original post was me, but I left for a while, and when I returned, it was with a different screen name. I did wind up buying 3 paw paw trees, from a local nursery. We finalized on the place in July, so that was when I bought them. Not wanting to wait until the next year. I planted carefully, and watered every week that first summer. I was surprised they survived, but they did. The varieties were Sunflower, NC-1, and Rebecca's Gold. I since read that RG is a bad choice due to being later, didn't know that then. At the end of the trees' 3rd fall now, NC-1 grew the best, now 5 feet tall, Sunflower a bit less, 4 feet tall. RG was eaten off twice by rabbits, but has grown to all of 18 inches tall now with a protective screen in place. This spring, NC-1 and Sunflower both bloomed, but neither fruited despite my playing the fly with a paintbrush. I still don't know if they will fruit at my place in Battleground WA, but it looks promising they survived. It was very foggy when I took the photo. It gives a general idea of the tree's growth compared to other species I planted the same year....See MoreBest way to handle only partly dead river birch
Comments (6)I did cut of the trunk down to the highest water sucker growing out of it. First did a scratch test and the trunk showed no green, but when I cut it off I could see the slightest bit of green beneath the bark. Maybe I should have waited until that part of the trunk turned brittle, but now at least the tree can at least put its effort toward making food and feeding its roots with those lower water sucker branches that are growing out of the trunk. Then maybe next year the roots will be established well enough to send up some shoots from the roots and I could then cut the old trunk down and allow the tree to focus its efforts on developing new multiple main leader trunks that should have better balance between them in trunk diameter....See More3 trees, 3 options...your thoughts on the best route
Comments (15)John - no problem digging longer roots, except that you want to maintain the soil around the roots as much as possible (vs exposing them) to help maintain the small hairline roots - these are the roots that absorb water and nutrients and oxygen from the soil. And soil is heavy, especially wet soil in the spring. Digging around the roots, lifting the soil and roots, --and transporting this mass without it falling apart -- is a key problem. Access is usually difficult, beech seldom seems to grow near the edge of the forest (unless the area has been cleared) -- likes a bit of dampness , and when you are digging up your specimen, if possible you don't want to destroy other saplings. Generally, smaller diameter stems are easier to transplant, and have better survival rates - like 1 - 2 inch diameter. Larger stems demand a larger root-soil mass, and volume being a cubic function, weight increases fast. As others have mentioned, beech is a finicky tree about where it grows. It seems to prefer well drained soil, with a bit of dampness and deeper layers of humus with rotting leaves above does help with survival. I have seen Beech grow on clay -- with difficulty. Carefully examine the site where your specimen tree is growing, and try to duplicate it as much as possible for best success. And you want the newly planted root mass to be at the same level as the area it grew in., If you succeed, beech is a great long-lived tree. Sorry, I can't help you with mail order. I am based in Ontario, Canada -- well away from New Jersey, BUt, a local nursery or a landscape architect or a possibly a local arborist could name some good sources. If the company you normally deal with hasn't got what you want, it may be that what you want hasn't got a good survival rate, or such a good survival rate, there is no point carrying the species....See MoreBest fruit trees to plant in the Pacific Northwest?
Comments (8)Because of the damp, mild climate west of the Cascades, fungal diseases on fruit trees can be common, so it is smart to select varieties that are known for their disease resistance. The primary issues with cherries is more focused on the ornamental or flowering kinds - fruiting cherries actually do pretty well here with minimal issues. Some of the most popular kinds or cherries: Lapins (self-fertile), Rainier, Stella, Sweetheart, any of the sour cherries. Avoid Bing - they are prone to splitting here. Apples: Chehalis, Liberty, Akane, Honeycrisp, Fuji, Jonagold, Gravenstein (has some disease issues but still a very popular selection). Avoid Red or Golden Delicious - they don't do well west of the Cascades. Pears - any of the popular European and Asian pears are fine for this area. Highly recommended European pears are Rescue, Orcas, Bartlett, Bosc and Ubileen. Chojuro, Shinseiki and Nijisseiki (aka 20th Century) are among the most popular Asian selections but any seem to do well here About the only peach recommended for this area is Frost, which is also leaf curl resistant. Apricots, nectarines and any of the hybrid fruits (pluots, apriums, plumcots, etc.) are just not suited to this climate and tend not to be successful. I would urge you to locate and purchase your trees from a local nursery or garden center, not from a box store like Costco or Home Depot. Local nurseries tend to carry fruit tree varieties best suited to the rather unique growing conditions of the Pacific Northwest, whereas the larger box stores seldom offer the most regionally appropriate choices. There are a couple of great resources available to fruit growers west of the Cascades. The first is the WSU Fruit Trial website, which is a compilation of about 5 decades of research into the best fruit varieties for west of the Cascades. The second is Raintree Nursery, located in Morton, WA by Mt. St. Helens. Raintree is a huge mail order fruit source, selling all across the country, however they also specialize in fruit types best for our area. They are happy to chat over the phone to help you pick what will work best for you....See Morefragaria
16 years agoEmbothrium
16 years agoEmbothrium
16 years agomkirkwag
16 years agoEmbothrium
16 years agoplantknitter
16 years agoEmbothrium
16 years agoEmbothrium
16 years ago
Related Stories

GARDENING GUIDESTop 10 Native Plants for the Pacific Northwest
More than just gorgeous and adaptable, these standout plants convey a sense of place
Full Story
NORTHWEST GARDENINGPacific Northwest Gardener's March Checklist
Prepare for edible harvests and invite feathered friends to the garden — offering them slugs for lunch is entirely up to you
Full Story
GARDENING GUIDESPacific Northwest Gardener's August Checklist
Deadheading perennials, cutting raspberry canes and preparing for the onion harvest keeps Northwest gardeners busy in August
Full Story
GARDENING AND LANDSCAPINGGarden Lessons from a Grand Northwest Reserve
Borrow classic landscape ideas from this Washington state treasure, a series of gardens as thoughtfully planned as they are spacious
Full Story
HOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: Elegant Simplicity in a Midcentury Northwest Remodel
A discerning couple in Washington collaborate with a friend to update and add to their modern home
Full Story
NORTHWEST GARDENINGPacific Northwest Gardener's January Checklist
Planning, pruning and planting now will help your garden flourish in the coming year
Full Story
LANDSCAPE DESIGNGreat Design Plant: Quaking Aspen for 3-Season Beauty — on Its Own Turf
It offers bright fall foliage, snowy winter bark and lush green leaves in summer. Just don't try to plant quaking aspen away from its home
Full Story
WINTER GARDENING8 Gorgeous Trees for Winter Interest in the Garden
Intriguing forms and beautiful branches take center stage when color heads back into the wings of the winter landscape
Full Story
EDIBLE GARDENSHow to Grow 10 Favorite Fruit Trees at Home
Plant a mini orchard in fall, winter or early spring to enjoy fresh-off-the-tree fruit the following year
Full Story
SIDE YARD IDEASNarrow Trees for Tight Garden Spaces
Boost interest in a side yard or another space-challenged area with the fragrance and color of these columnar trees
Full Story
silver_creek