how much water is too much water?

17 years ago

I started planting heirlooms last year and only had success with the cherries. This year I planted 10 different heirlooms because I'm crazy. I'm trying to avoid mistakes I think I may have made last year.

1. how often should I water? I keep reading conflicting info..some say to consistently water, others only to water every few days.

2. when do I know the tomatoes are watered enough? when can I tell that they need water?

3. how do I get a nice slow watering without touching the leaves (and no I can't afford an underground hose system)?

4. I am doing both containers and in the ground tomatoes...are there different levels of moisture I should be giving them each time I water?

and this is slightly unrelated but - which are best? tomato cages or ladders?

thanks to all the expert opinions.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (2)

feldon30
17 years ago
I know it sounds counterintuitive, but tomato-specific questions get their best results in the Tomato forums.

I think the Heirlooms forum is primarily for the culture and history involved in heirlooms and how people get and distribute seeds. Growing, not so much...

That said...

1) Well that's easy -- as much as the plants need! :) Seriously, you don't want to waterlog your plants, and keeping the soil wet at all times can lead to a host of problems. I water every couple of days and never let the soil get "dry", always keeping above "moist".

3) A soaker hose.

4) I've found watering in containers to be much more difficult than in-ground. What kind of soil did you put in the containers?

The 54" tomato cages they sell at Home Depot, Lowe's, etc. will NOT support 6 to 8' tall heirloom tomato plants. You will need to make your own cages out of concrete reinforcing mesh or something else or buy the very expensive Texas Tomato Cages ($17/each if you buy 6).
greenwitch
17 years ago
As much as they need. When the plants are small, water when the first inch or so of the top soil is dry, this could be everyday if the weather is warm or windy. As they grow, you water at greater intervals and you water deeper to encourage the roots to grow down and out - tomato roots can extend 6' except when in containers of course. If you water too much, the plants produce vegetative growth, stems and foliage. If there is any risk that their lives are going to end (stress) i.e. drought, flowers and fruit are produced. So don't make them too happy, but don't stress them so far that they can't recover. Growing them fast (lots of water and fertilizer) can lead to predatory insects, wind breakage and collapse, growing them hard (moderate water and fertilizer) leads to longer lived plants and reproduction (flowers/fruits). So, there is no substitute for daily observation and accessment of the weather and soil conditions. Also, veggies and fruit given the time to grow slowly absorb more minerals from the soil and have a higher nutritional content. Isn't that a good reason to have a home garden (good taste too)?
Related Discussions
How much water is too much?
Q
Comments (16)
Hey hey, Paula, you are a bit under the weather there!!! OMG, that is more rain than we got a couple of weeks ago....and I thought 17 inches in 36 hours was a lot. You have topped that. However, it will dry out quickly,and you will be having to water things again. Like we were initially supposed to have a piece of that storm system. Don't you know we have not gotten a DROP of rain!!! Too bad, because I held off watering expecting to be inundated with it. So tomorrw after I visit the doc, I'll be watering again. Before we reach the 101 degrees predicted for next week, I'm moving things yet again to a shadier spot. Even though it says "shade tolerant" I think that shade is pretty well lit up. I lost one plant with the rain, it was Eskimo Pie, because there was a broken piece of pottery in the bottom of the pot, and it blocked the drain hole. I did not see it until the heat began again, and the petiole keeled over. We only had about 4 inches of water standing in a good part of the garden, so not as bad as you have it in Jax. Keep your powder dry, not exactly sure what to say about your potted plants. Any high ground? In Louisiana there is a saying, It's hard to remember your intent was to drain the swamp when you're knee deep in alligators.
...See More
How much water-based poly is too much?
Q
Comments (11)
The number of coats is completely irrelevant. It depends on the product. It depends on the method of application. The important thing is to read and follow the directions provided by the manufacturer. For water base finishes, there are a couple of rules that you MUST follow: 1. Do not apply water base finishes at temperatures below 65 F. That is the most important rule to follow! Many things will go wrong if the temperatures are too cold. A white or cloudy appearance is from the cold. Be sure everything is at the proper temperature: the work piece, the finish, and the air. 2. Allow each coat to dry properly before recoating. If you can't sand the previous coat of finish and produce powder, it is not dry enough. Do not attempt to put on all the coats the same day, even if the can says one hour recoat. Two coats per day is the max! 3. Choose the application method based on how thick of a coating you desire. Wiping on a finish leaves the thinnest coat. More coats are necessary to build a durable film. Brushes lay on a thicker coating that levels out as it dries. If you brush too thin, it leaves brush marks; brush too heavy and you get runs. I doubt you'll be using spray equipment, so I won't go there. I'd say that 3 wet coats applied with a brush would be ideal. With a rag, you may need 5 or more coats to achieve a durable film.
...See More
Too much sun?? Too much water??
Q
Comments (4)
Was that cactus green at one point? Is it mushy? I just left my plants for six days, the temps were between 90-100 degrees during the day. I watered all my plants the day I left (watering until water came out of the drainage holes in the bottom of the pots) I didn't water them at all until the 6th day when I returned home, and I had no problems. My staghorn fern was a little wilted but bounced right back after being watered. My point is, one of the best things about succulents is they can handle some neglect every once in awhile. Unless I'm leaving for several weeks I don't let anyone touch my plants. The only instructions I left for the person who lives on my property was to not touch/water them. If your cactus isn't mushy than its probably a lighting issues. The other plants with the exception of that brown one in the long planter all look ok and if they looked different than when you left them they should bounce back. When in doubt don't water. I have a haworthia coarctata that will turn very dark green when exposed to a lot of light. Unless it's burned, the burn spots are obvious and white. It had gotten a burn spot when I first brought it home, the burn was on a lower leaf which I was able to cover with gravel but now it's hardly noticeable.
...See More
Too Much Summer Water The Die. Lots of Winter Water and They Grow?
Q
Comments (26)
@spanishfly the point of perched water is that it can be bone dry at the top of the pot while the bottom can be a swamp where roots drown. You can't guess about the conditions at the bottom based on eyeing anything outside the pot. Just because the pot is terra cotta doesn't mean you escape the consequences of using a soil mixture that retains too much water. Why wouldn't you just test for water at the bottom of the pot with a skewer? It's so cheap to buy a pack of 100 skewers that they are basically free. The biggest impact I ever had on growing cactus and succulents was switching over to gritty mix. I would say the ability for the soil to drain - and minimize perched water - is everything to these kinds of plants. I couldn't disagree more strongly that this has no relevance in a small pot. You might be side-stepping this issue if you under-water, which cactus generally love. If you have a soil mixture that retains too much water you might not have a long-term problem because so much time is passing between waterings that even a soil mixture that retains too much water would dry out. But that is just a kind of learned compensation for whatever water retention characteristics your particular soil mixture has.
...See More

how much water is too much water?

Comments (2)

feldon30

greenwitch

Related Discussions

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US