Changing Water to "Flush Out" Potentially Harmful Substances

10 years ago

I tried planting herbs for the first time a couple weeks ago. I have parsley, sweet marjoram, and dill in three small pots that I originally put on top of the refrigerator to keep them warm, but it didn't work.

I had the idea of putting them in my empty fish tank since the light could keep them warm (and, obviously, give them light). It's been working, but the only problem is that I put them in the last half inch or so of water that was left in there from when I had fish in it. I don't know what I was thinking. I know that was a stupid move. That water hasn't been filtered for a few weeks now.

So, I cleaned out the fish tank and put the pots back in their little dishes, which I filled with clean water. I have a light on the plants now, but not a lid. I'm hoping the water will evaporate off the plants and take some of the potentially hazardous materials that were in the fish water with it.

If I replace the water often enough, will the herbs be safe to eat? Also, I've read as long as you cook the herbs enough most of the germs will be killed.

Any thoughts? Will the plants be safe or should I throw them away?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
10 years ago
Tip all the water out of the 'little dishes'. Plants do not want to be standing in water. If you are concerned about whatever was in the fish water you need to water the pots thoroughly in the sink and leave them there until they stop dripping from the holes in the bottom of the pots. Then replace them where you are trying to grow them. Only time will tell if there is enough light in the fish tank but imo they'd be happier in the brightest window sill you have.
balloonflower
10 years ago
Are you concerned just about the fish part, or was the water containing some sort of green slime or something. If it's just the fish poo, you may not have a problem. I've seen aquaponics systems used to grow herbs in the same water as fish, which provide good nutrients for the plants.

Agree with Flora on not leaving them standing in water. You may be okay in the fish tank--I use the same sort of system in a dry tank when starting seedlings to try and contain some heat under lights.
Related Discussions
White chalk-like fungus/substance on plants
Q
Comments (17)
I once had this problem until I started spraying with dawn dish soap and water. Seems to work. Inspect them every couple of days or so and spray generously until gone. It takes work but worth the effort. You should also cut off the infected branches and spray where the growth (closer to roots) starts. This is the area where these bugs live or colonize (so to speak).
...See More
Benefits of water change?
Q
Comments (20)
Bailing I am sorry but I do not understand how you came up with only a 6% water change by overflowing the when adding 10% of the volume of the pond. The only way I can see that happening is if there is no mixing of water going on in the pond and the water is added at the surface very near the point where the water overflows out of the pond. First let's assume that there is very good mixing of water going on in the pond. Then as you add water water starts to go out at the same rate that you add. So when you have added the first 1% of the volume it has mixed with the 100% of the pond water and 1% has overflowed of which 1% is fresh water and 99% is old water. Continue this up to the point where 10% has been changed then about 95% old water is out and 5% of new water is lost. Now let's assume there is no mixing of pond water. Then as water is added some water leaves but there is no way to predict weather new or old water is going to leave. But since the water you are adding is probably cooling then the water in the pond it is going to be more dense and will sink to the bottom and not be part of the water that overflowed. But if there is no mixing going on in the pond you probably don't need to do very many water changes as if there are very many fish they are not going to be very healthy in any case. If all you have in your water that you are adding is chlorine and are adding 5% or less and there is good aeration going on you are usually safe in not adding water conditioner to the water. If you have water lilies in the pond they with remove heavy metals from the pond quickly usually in less then 24 hours. Mike
...See More
White substance on Broms
Q
Comments (2)
Hee hee, nice toenails, purplestar! ;-) Ah yes, dried algae. It's not harmful to the plant at all, it just looks ugly. I find it is easier to remove on a rainy day when it has had time to soften up in the rain. Just briefly getting it wet isn't always enough, although the big fibrous chunks should come off pretty easily as you describe. I've always thought it would be interesting to try and make paper out of that stuff! You're right, you don't want to scrape it off with your fingernail or anything, that will leave marks. A damp rag or sponge might help, or if you can get a hose shut-off nozzle that will close down to a very fine but fairly hard spray, that should help blast some of it off too. I sometimes swab the leaves with a cotton ball soaked in alcohol if I'm trying to remove scale or mealybug, and that seems to clean off any other deposits on the leaves as well. This is safe for the plant as long as it doesn't get really direct sunlight while you're doing it. If you can keep your cups flushed out with fresh water all the time you can keep the algae from growing (and the mosquitos too). This is a lot easier if you just have a few plants than if you have hundreds.
...See More
white flakey substance in pool HELP
Q
Comments (12)
We have the same problem... We build new house last year...Our pool builder Intercoastal Pool and Spa in Melbourne, Fl said it was salt dandruff and that Pentair intellichlor is pre-disposed to salt dandruff...However Pentair told us it's not the chlorinator but it's a combination of pH being too high and alkninitity being off... Long story short... a local pool store suggested using product called Jack's Magic Magenta Stuff http://www.jacksmagic.com/products/JMMAGENTA032.html It worked.... we have 18,000 pool and one quart worked..first vacuum up "dranduff"...then pour in whole bottle. I"m going to start adding about 5 oz's weekly of it to see if it will prevent dandruff from coming back.... When I first used the product it kept it at bay for about 3 months... Good luck.
...See More
mariahadams
Original Author
10 years ago
I've been replacing the water in the dishes every day. I've been putting them in the dishes because it's actually a Chia brand herb garden kit, and it's got the soil sponges that are supposed to take in only as much water as they need. But I'll go ahead and start watering them in the sink.

I put them in the tank with the light more for heat purposes than for light. It's been very cold here.

I wasn't so much worried about the fish stuff as I was about the water conditioner. It was made specifically for fish, and I didn't know if it was safe for people.

My dill has been growing really well. A lot of the seeds have been growing. I have new tall ones every day. The marjoram is growing pretty well too. I pull out some of the tallest ones every evening so it doesn't get overgrown.

The parsley isn't growing at all though. What should I do?
balloonflower
10 years ago
Parsley has a very long germination time. Do a little research and figure based from when you planted.
mariahadams
Original Author
10 years ago
Geez, four to six weeks. Thanks for the tip. I hope it works. I guess I should have been able to figure that out myself, but the other two seemed to start growing almost at the same time. I'll keep watering it and see what happens.
floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
10 years ago
Can you post a picture? Then we can advise you whether your seedlings look healthy or not.

You didn't mention to start with that this was a kit and that it had 'sponges' so I was advising based on growing conventionally in a mix. I have no experience of this product so can't comment on how likely it is to succeed. I looked it up and 3 inches is a minute pot for growing a reasonable plant of any of the herbs listed. You may well get some young plants and a few tastes of herbs but for longer term herb growing you will need to move the plants to appropriate containers or the garden.
nancyjane_gardener
10 years ago
Floral- I agree about putting them in larger pots! Some herbs can get HUGE!
I wonder why it is that some companies have these kits that will grow in those tiny pots? I would use those herbs up in a week!
Mariah, if you really like fresh herbs, get these planted into larger containers! Once you start cooking with fresh herbs you WILL get addicted! LOL Add sage, rosemary,tarragon, thyme and oregano to your other herbs.
You don't even have to be a great cook to impress your friends with dishes made with fresh herbs! Even sprinkled on a salad will freshen it up and make it fun! Nancy

Changing Water to "Flush Out" Potentially Harmful Substances

Comments (7)

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

balloonflower

Related Discussions

mariahadams
Original Author

balloonflower

mariahadams
Original Author

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

nancyjane_gardener

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Changing Water to "Flush Out" Potentially Harmful Substances

Comments (7)

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

balloonflower

Related Discussions

mariahadamsOriginal Author

balloonflower

mariahadamsOriginal Author

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

nancyjane_gardener

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

mariahadams
Original Author

mariahadams
Original Author