I think I have a problem with my pruning technique

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/

18 years ago

A few seasons ago I did some semi-major pruning on a crepe myrtle; this involved pruning the main trunks (three), which were about 1/2 inch in diameter at the time.

Today I noticed that each scar (three, one per trunk) has a crack, split down the middle and into the trunk. I am concerned that I pruned improperly but I don't know what I did wrong.

I have never noticed this happening on any of my other shrubs or crape myrtles. Please look at my photos and tell me what I might have done incorrectly, how I can do better next time, and what I can do to remediate the current problem.

Thanks,

-Melanie-

Comments (7)

patecake
18 years ago
The limb growing out is just to heavy for the stub that you left. Growing out at too much of an angle, also. Just go down to beneath the cracked part and cut it off there.
Next year when you prune it again, if you have a place with that much of a "Y", either snip it a few inches above the "Y", or take it off below the "Y" and that should prevent your problem again.
calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9
18 years ago
You cut into the branch collar espesially on the left side. It is better to leave a stub by cutting a little above the collar than to cut too low. Hormones located in the collar material help to seal up the edges of the cut and prevent the problem you have now. Al
Related Discussions
I think I have a problem
Q
Comments (12)
You are correct, "generic" certification is often meaningless. ISA (International Society of Arboriculture) certification is the gold standard. Certainly not all ISA certified arborists are equally qualified, but at least they tend to be consistently better than the guys that think they are qualified because they know how to get their Homelite saw started. Whether you need an ISA certified arborist to take down a tree this size depends. If the tree could fall and damage something, it's a good idea to get someone you can be confident in. If, however, the tree is just out in the middle of your yard, it doesn't look like much of a challenge and probably the guy that can get his saw started could do the job perfectly fine.
...See More
I think I may have gotten Brugmansia sap in my eye.. what to do?
Q
Comments (14)
Thanks to all who responded. Yes, my eye began slowly working it's way back to normal. After the first day, it had gone down to about half the size it was the night before, and was starting to show some response to light. By the second day, I was able to focus my eye again, and by the third, it seemed normal, if not still slightly sensitive to light. Those first 2 days I had to wear sunglasses even in the house because even the sunlight coming in the windows was painful. Definate lesson learned here, I think when working with these plants from now on, I will wear gardening gloves, as a precaution that I wont absently wipe or scratch my eyes, and be sure to wash thoughoughly upon coming back inside. Very scary indeed when you make a living as a freelance photographer and only have one good eye. (I was born with an abnormality of my left eye, looks perfectly normal but is basically just window dressing, can't do more than distinguish color and light with it) I couldn't imagine giving up our brugs, our yard is always vibrant with the colors of them, and on nights like last night, with literally thousands of open blooms, you realise why you do all that feeding and watering. We had a candlelight dinner and a movie on our lanai literally floating on clouds of the most wonderful perfume. Earlier in the evening just after dusk we were returning home with the windows open in the car and could literally smell our place before we arrived in front of the house. Appearantly the weather has just been on the perfect side for them this winter, as the trees are just bending under the weight of as many blossoms as they can possibly hold, with flushes coming one after the other. I haven't slowed my feeding scheduel yet, as it's been pretty much in the lower 80's still all the time, and have had to do quite a bit of pruning, both of side shoots and branches that are getting on the roof and in the gutters. So I should have plenty of cuttings if anybody wants them who didn't get some of the plants I had earlier, they went amazingley fast. Dave
...See More
I think I have a problem. . . . .
Q
Comments (25)
Finally I have determined that the hard drive is failing. I suddenly had the boot disk message appear several days ago, and when I checked the boot order in BIOS, noted that no hard disk is listed. In attempting to use recovery disks, got a message "No hard drive detected." I then opened the tower and checked the connections, which were good and tight. Did a little dusting while I had it open. Finally, today I went into BIOS setup and saw the hard drive listed and decided to run the SMART test from there. It failed with a notation of "7" and then something about "no read." Since I just bought this drive about a year ago, I checked Western Digital's site and found out that it has a 3 year warranty. I started filling out information online and hit a stone wall when I could not get the page for RMA instructions to load, so I ended up phoning. Once I gave the serial number and was asked the problem, I was offered a replacement using either of two choices. I chose to receive the new drive and then return the old one within 30 days. For this, I had to give them a credit card number so that in case I did not return the old drive, they would charge my credit card $45. I didn't want to have to ship the old one back and then wait for the new one; also I don't have a proper box to ship it in. This way I will ship it back in the box the new one is in. By the way, I did a full backup on Friday, so hopefully putting the OS and all my programs etc. back will not be such a hassle as using the rescue disks. I used my Acronis program to clone the entire hard drive to the external drive I have. I may come asking for help when the time comes to reverse the operation and put things back on the internal hard drive. Thanks everyone for your help and support.
...See More
Help! I don' think I've pruned my hydrangeas hard enough?
Q
Comments (7)
IME none of the hydrangeas need pruning to bloom well, though some may benefit from pruning to shape the plant or to control size. I generally don't prune mine at all, and I grow four different species and several cultivars of most of them. As GG48 suggested, look at the growing conditions, particularly the soil water and organic matter as well as amount and timing of shade. Does the plant have a good layer of mulch to help even out temperature and moisture levels? What are temperatures and soil conditions in your part of Australia? Do you do any supplemental watering? Once we know all that and the type of hydrangea you have (give us a name or a photo) you can get some more specific information to help them grow more happily for you.
...See More
melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author
18 years ago
Did I cut into the collar of the branch that is growing out to the right (in the photos)?

When I pruned I didn't remove branches; I cut the leader of each trunk because they were all sort of growing inward towards each other. How would I recognize the branch collar on a leader?

Which leads to my next question: if I cut them all back (off), below the crack, I will, again, be cutting the leader. Should I look for a dormant bud and be sure to leave a bid of leader behind to prevent the cracking?
youreit
18 years ago
According to Sunset's pruning section -

"When removing a branch, don't make a flush cut. Position your shears or saw just outside the branch collar, the wrinkled area (or bulge) at the branch's base where it meets another branch or the trunk [the area under the cut you show above]. Also refrain from cutting into the branch bark ridge (raised bark in the branch crotch) [the area over the cut you show above]. Leaving these areas intact keeps decay to a minimum."

Brenda
melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author
18 years ago
I appreciate the comments. Sounds like I cut into the collar of the branch growing off the leader/trunk.

I pruned the trunks on this tree, not the branch coming off, but I must have pruned too close.
calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9
18 years ago
melle sacto you are right. The leader you cut, being the leader, did not have a branch collar. However you should have cut the leader at more of a right angle which would have meant leaving a small stub. The stub left would have a smaller area and healed better, probably without the risk of the split which allows the moisture and possible bacteria to enter. Al
melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author
18 years ago
Al, thanks for the tips. I didn't want to leave any stubs when I pruned but now I see that was a mistake. I'm glad I learned this lesson now, while I'm still young and haven't ruined anything significiant :-)

I think I have a problem with my pruning technique

Comments (7)

patecake

calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9

Related Discussions

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author

youreit

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author

calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

I think I have a problem with my pruning technique

Comments (7)

patecake

calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9

Related Discussions

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/Original Author

youreit

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/Original Author

calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author

melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
Original Author