Baltimore Checkerspots may actually be Harris' Checkerspots?

15 years ago

Sigh, I may not have Baltimores afterall. I thought it might be a possibility because I read how close the two species are. Someone from Native plants forum thinks the plants I found these guys on is aster umbrellatus (sp?), which is the host plant for Harris'.

I took a close up picture, and I will quote David Wagner below. What do you all think? Also, I got a pic of the chrysalis. It's cloudy put today, and the chrysalis is in an awkwars position, so I couldn't get a shot where I could see the focus well. I only got one decent pic. Maryann, I'm hoping you'll read this and see if this looks like a BC. But then, would the two species chrysalises look alike?

Wagner's description about the differences between the two:

"Caterpillars of Harris' have more T2 and A9 with more orange, transverse orange bands are interrupted at the level of the sphericles, and small yellow spots follow sphericles on A1-A8. Branches of dorsal scoli needlelike, less than half the height of the scolus; in Baltimores, more hairlike, nearly as long as scolus height."

I'm not sure I understand all of the scolus stuff...does he mean the little hairs off the original scolus, the one that emerges out of the caterpillar?

Thanks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

larry_gene
15 years ago
Not having top-of-the-head knowledge, I did a little reading.

The scoli (scolus is singular) are the rows of projections and may bear hairs (setae) or spines.

From the Wagner description, your photo looks like a Harris, the scoli are bearing needle-like, relatively short spines.

I would question Wagner's use of the word "sphericles" (sphere-shaped) rather than the word "spiracles" (related to the word reSPIRate).

Perhaps ladobe or others could confirm or clarify this.
bernergrrl
Original Author
15 years ago
Hi Larry Gene, Yep, typo :) it's spiracles.

And I am no longer in denial that I have Harris'; last night I looked at this side-by-side comparison tool NABA has, and it's easy to see then the orange that Harris' has on the T2 and A9 (right behind the head and right at the end of the caterpillar). The chrysalis also doesn't look like a Baltimore Checkerspot one.

Oh well,they're still pretty cool, and I'm glad that I have the correct habitat for them since their populations are on the downward trend due to loss of habitat.

Here is a link that might be useful: NABA Side-by_Side Butterfly comparison
Related Discussions
Baltimore cats alive and well...
Q
Comments (13)
Maryann, There's nothing wrong with being obsessed about something that's so nice as Baltimore Checkerspots! :) I hope they would like the habitat that we have here. It's rural but not real rural. We live along a road that gets pretty much traffic and our neighbors are just on the other side of our driveway, so even though it's considered rural it doesn't always feel that way, especially when the neighbor's dog barks almost all the time. :( I'm really sorry that you don't think you can transplant the BCs there at your place. So you bring the cats home to raise and then release the butterflies there at your place, right? Do you mean that they don't stick around after you release them? I don't know how big your backyard is, so it's hard to tell if you could keep them there or not. Well, besides, it's not like I'm an expert. I sure wish it would work out for you though. I think you might have said before, but could you describe what the area is like where you go to collect the BC cats? You say they like a marshy area. Isn't that where a lot of water stands? Now I'm wondering what the different is between a marsh and a swamp? Is there standing water where you go for the cats? Is the vegetation real soggy that you sink into mud? Is it an area that gets mowed or is it let natural? I'm just trying to decide if our little 1/8 acre field would suit the BCs. It borders a creek and is wet in the spring that you can't walk in it without sinking into the mud and losing your shoes. lol When summer comes along, though, the field dries up. So I don't know if the butterflies would like it there or not. I plan on planting the plants there that I mentioned above, and I also want to plant some Swamp Milkweed there for the Monarchs. I can't wait to see pictures of your cats and butterflies again this year! :) Cathy
...See More
Chelone for Baltimore Checkerspots
Q
Comments (3)
Well, that's true; it's not like I would have bought it for nothing...someone will like it. I don't know if it's a good nectar plant for butterflies or not. I like hummingbirds and hang feeders for them, so if they like this plant, then they'll be happy that I bought it. It would be nice to attrac some BCs, but I'm not betting on it. I don't know how long you've been trying to get BC's with the Chelone glabra, but I hope that they show up there someday.
...See More
Over-wintering Silvery Checkerspots
Q
Comments (6)
Thank you Jeff and runmede!!! I have found several batches...all on my coneflowers. I will put some on the potted coneflower in a screened "cat" house and cover some of the ones outside on the garden plants. Thanks for the info....I am so anxious to actually get to see their chrysalises...the pictures I've seen are so tiny...it would be a treat to actually see them in person! I have another question! I assume as it won't be cold here for quite awhile that they go dormant before the cold hits and hide at the base of the plant then? It seems if they keep active..eating and growing until the cold they would get way bigger than I assume they will actually get. I guess I am just wondering what to expect so I don't worry that something is wrong and not the natural cycle. Thanks again!! Joan
...See More
Baltimore checkerspots - my next goal
Q
Comments (8)
You just need an area that is wet in the spring. A wet meadow. But, dries up in the summer. You need about 25 Chelone plants to start. I use C. glabra and C. obliqua. What Chelone is native to your state. I've been raising Baltimore Checkerspots since spring of 2006 and have learned a lot about them. I just put together a power point presentation to teach a group in Maryland how to breed them. Near the area where the turtlehead is growing, you must have a meadow that contains nectar sources. During the first year, they use the Chelone to lay on, then web up and don't eat too much. Then, they winter over and emerge in April. Then, is when the eating begins and they eat a lot more different species of plants. I have a very long list of plants that they eat in the second year. So far, I think it contains 20 different types of plants.
...See More
MissSherry
15 years ago
I looked at the pictures in my books yesterday, and, due to the lack of a large black area near the head, your cat looked like Harris' checkerspot, not a Baltimore. Still, not having raised any myself, I thought I'd wait for somebody else's opinion.
Harris' checkerspots are beautiful, too, BG!
Sherry
bernergrrl
Original Author
15 years ago
Thanks MissSherry. I was soooo stoked to have Baltimores. Maybe they'll still show up. It's been a fun season discovering these caterpillars that overwinter--all new to me! Seems to be so many of them too--it's amazing how they do it, these seemingly fragile creatures.

I've also learned from this experience where T2 and A9 are. :) I'm surprised my eyes still work today from all of the squinting and comparing that I was doing.
ladobe
15 years ago
Spiracles is correct for the abdominal/thoracic vents of an insects closed respiratory system.

From Latin... spiraculum - spirare. To breathe (respiro).

Even educated Lepidopterists misspell/misuse (mispronounce) terms at times, but it's really sad if it makes it into print without being caught and corrected by the author.
bernergrrl
Original Author
15 years ago
Ooops, sorry, the typo was mine, not Wagner's. I was trying to type from a book on a lap top precariously positioned on the couch and keep an eye on DD at the same time.
susanlynne48
15 years ago
BG - I admire you - the fact that you do as much Butterfly Gardening as you do, with a baby! Incredible!

Susan

Baltimore Checkerspots may actually be Harris' Checkerspots?

Comments (7)

larry_gene

bernergrrl
Original Author

Related Discussions

MissSherry

bernergrrl
Original Author

ladobe

bernergrrl
Original Author

susanlynne48

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Baltimore Checkerspots may actually be Harris' Checkerspots?

Comments (7)

larry_gene

bernergrrlOriginal Author

Related Discussions

MissSherry

bernergrrlOriginal Author

ladobe

bernergrrlOriginal Author

susanlynne48

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

bernergrrl
Original Author

bernergrrl
Original Author

bernergrrl
Original Author