SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
growing_rene2

May I have some white rose suggestions, please?

growing_rene2
10 years ago

I planted 8 rose bushes for mothers day & I am a bit unhappy with my no-name white tea hybrid. I am hoping there is a nice white that does not turn brown within a day after full bloom (no discoloration would be preferable). I would like it to remain close to 6', as I am wanting them all to just mingle. In the (day 1) photo, it is the small one in front of the red bloom. I am in Western, NC...though not the Mtns (Michael, I am down the mountain from you). Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance!

René

Comments (41)

  • susan4952
    10 years ago

    What type of rose do you prefer? I have so many whites and blends. And I am in Chicago, which is tougher. Love blanc double de Coubert, pope John Paul 2, Anastasia, Bolero, Tineke, JFK, Crysatlline, Snowbird, Majesty, and so many others. Whites can be a challenge.

  • dublinbay z6 (KS)
    10 years ago

    I don't grow it, but lots of posters on this forum recommend Pope John Paul 2 as a wonderful white hybrid tea. Tineke is another good one.

    Kate

  • Related Discussions

    I need some suggestions please. . .

    Q

    Comments (4)
    I love, love, love my Chicago Apache daylilies - and I don't even like red, lol! :) Dee P.S. I hesitated to put this particular link in, since when I called it up the first review was not favorable. But this is the best photo in terms of color, IMO. Just the like color in real life in my garden. Here is a link that might be useful: Chicago Apache
    ...See More

    May I have some good thoughts, please?

    Q

    Comments (22)
    Lots of prayers going up for Wally! Yea...if he has that external bag not many people will know except the ones he choses to tell. Wally will be back on that golf course in no time...bag or not bag!!! I have a couple friends with a colonestomy bag, no one but a chosen few know they have it. You could never tell. Deb
    ...See More

    ..the May garden...some early roses...

    Q

    Comments (24)
    Thank you so much, Marlorena. Yes, I meant the pot sitting on the gravel. I was toying with the idea of box for my lg. pot, clipped into a globe. My garden is anything but formal, so didn't know if that would work. I like the idea of it set it at a juncture of the pathways. I've been wanting to incorporate Hakone grass into the garden, so could use that instead, with the pot in a shadier area. Now, I'm going to look at your photos again! Nothing blooming here, yet.
    ...See More

    rose died and went to rootstock. Now I have some original back?????

    Q

    Comments (15)
    vaporvac totally agree although I did loose 2 our of 3 of my velvet fragrance roses even after 5 years. They were small cuttings at first, got fairly big then after the deer pruning them constantly they eventually died off. Only one left, its been over 10 years and the poor thing is still struggling. If its targeted it will have a bad year, if its left half way alone it can do alright. Having a new dog helps a little but not alot
    ...See More
  • growing_rene2
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    So far I love the floribundas & hybrid teas. However, I am starting to look more at the antiques and do not yet have any. I also like the nice blends.
    Thank you for the suggestions Susan and Kate!

  • nickl
    10 years ago

    Rene:

    kate has already given you two recommended HTs. We grow both and I can only second those recommendations. - "PJP2" has the added advantage of very nice fragrance.. "Tineke" tends to be a bit tender, but based on your zone it should be OK for you. "White Sail" is another fragrant white HT that has been recommended for warmer zones.

    We don't grow any white floribundas ourselves, but 'Moondance' has been highly recommended.

    As far as OGRs are concerned, you should not have any problem finding a white one. There are many good white OGRs (we grow a few ourselves). But be aware that OGRs tend to grow very large and may take up a lot more space than a typical HT or floribunda. Suggest you post on the Antique Rose forum here - I'm sure you'll get many suggestions.

    This post was edited by nickl on Sat, Jul 6, 13 at 11:18

  • michaelg
    10 years ago

    A closeup to show what type of discoloration you are getting would be helpful. Some white roses turn brown when they fade, and hang on the bush. Many are susceptible to botrytis petal blight in our frequent cool rains. This fungus causes moldy brown spots, rotting of the outer petals, buds sticking together and failing to open (balling), and, in some varieties, pink spotting. Also most white roses readily show damage from thrips, which cause brown dry petal tips and a scratched-up, scruffy look.

    I like the OGR 'Kronprinzessin Viktoria' which is resistant to botrytis and a great bloomer. It gets 4' high and wide but can be kept a bit smaller. KpV is more resistant to blackspot than white HTs but benefits from spraying here. 'Bolero' has a very beautiful and fragrant flower. A compact grower, it is somewhat resistant to BS but susceptible to botrytis. 'Katerina Zeimet' is a nice, low-growing polyantha with many small, fragrant flowers.

    Decades ago, when it was colder, I lost several white HT and Fl to winter kill, so I got out of the habit of replacing them. I think all white HTs will need spraying. I haven't grown PJP. 'Tineke' was resistant to botrytis. 'Garden Party' is a tough and beautiful old HT that is winter-hardy.

  • rosetom
    10 years ago

    I second the recommendation of Pope John Paul II as a perfectly white, exhibition form HT. It's the best white I've seen.

    I've had Crystalline for years, it certainly has outstanding blooms that are perfectly white and with wonderful fragrance, but the bush sucks. 10+ years on it and it still won't bloom without having to support the stems. It's also a BS magnet and has to be sprayed consistently.

  • growing_rene2
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Thank you all so much for all of these recommendations. Michael, below is a picture of what the petals look like today. I really have not done much pruning this week due to all of the rain...and that may be my biggest problem. ? Garden party is on my wish list. Since it is pretty tough, that may be the one I need, as a newbie. Again, thank you all so much!

  • lesmc
    10 years ago

    I would like to suggest Guinevere. This is my favorite white rose ...always in bloom...no black spot...no brown edges. I don`t hear much about this rose and I don`t understand why. As a mature bush here,it grows 3-4ft tall and 3 ft wide. I also love PPII and Bolero. My Garden Party is a beautiful rose also. Good Luck with your choice. I love a beautiful white rose!! Lesley

  • michaelg
    10 years ago

    René, I see why you are unhappy with that rose! The brown spots could be botrytis fungus, worst in cool rainy weather.

  • michaelg
    10 years ago

    lesmc, are you recommending the rose sold by Heirloom as "Queen Guinevere," aka HAReasy, Sir Galahad, and Great North Eastern Rose? I am not sure which is the official ARS common name. Harkness has released several roses named "Guinevere," but Heirloom applied the name to this rose.

    I have never heard anything about HAReasy (or whatever) and would be glad to get details of your experience, or others' experiences, with it.

  • susan4952
    10 years ago

    Rene, you need to seriously deadhead.

  • susan4952
    10 years ago

    Some of my whites.

  • growing_rene2
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Yeah, not happy with them at all. I usually cut them back in the evenings, except for this week. However, these roses turn brown very quickly & do not keep a nice bloom for any length of time. Susan, I think I am slowly giving up on these and have paid attention to my prettier roses in this rainy mess... prioritizing. I might go ahead & dead head in between the next set of showers; They do look horrible :(
    Thanks a bunch everyone!

  • growing_rene2
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    Those are very pretty, much closer to what I want!!

  • lesmc
    10 years ago

    michaelg....the rose I am speaking of is a floribuna rose by Harkness sold by Roses Unlimited.I am not familiar with the Heirloom rose you mention. I am not as knowledgable as most of the rose growers on this forum, just know what works in my garden and Guinevere has been outstanding. When first opening there is a pink tint which quickly disappears. The blooms last a long time on the bush and when cut. Bloom,bloom,bloom. Hope this answers your question. Happy 4th! Lesley

  • meredith_e Z7b, Piedmont of NC, 1000' elevation
    10 years ago

    I have a floribunda (I think) called Sans Souci that is a very nice white most of the year here. She works no-spray! The flowers last nicely on the bush. That impressed me.

    In cool whether, she is apricot/cream in the center. But she's white most of the time (here).

    I don't know her final height yet. I'd say at least 4 ft, but I don't know if she'll make 6. Great rose, though :)

  • rosetom
    10 years ago

    Garden Party? Not really a white when it gets blushed with pink fairly consistently. Mine does OK:
    {{gwi:311040}}
    {{gwi:311041}}
    ;-)

  • meredith_e Z7b, Piedmont of NC, 1000' elevation
    10 years ago

    Oooooh for Garden Party above!

    I looked up Sans Souci, and I have the Barni floribunda from RU, yes. Mine'll be at least 4 ft, but YMMV :) Great rose! Nice form and stays that way a while.

    Iceberg is nice, too! Those are all the 'specimen' whites I grow. I recommend noisettes and 'groundcover' roses like Alba Meidland (that one is really great as a 'landscape rose'), but for bigger blooms, I recommend the Barni Sans Souci out of my limited experience with whites.

    For an OGR that works in modern beds, I love Coquettes des Blanches (one of those words is singular, but I forget which). She's a Bourbon, but her repeat is awesome and she's very healthy. She starts out the most gorgeous barely-pink, but that quickly changes to white all the time here. Mine isn't fully grown, but in 2 years she's not shown any monster tendencies. I'd say she doesn't last as long as Sans Souci, though. She has those thinner petals. I recommend her highly, and she's white more times of the year than Sans Souci.

    This post was edited by meredith_e on Thu, Jul 4, 13 at 22:15

  • ND1964
    10 years ago

    I have PJP and I am very happy with it. Got it from Jackson and Perkins 2 years ago

  • ratdogheads z5b NH
    10 years ago

    I highly recommend the floribunda Moondance pictured here. It has clusters of large creamy white flowers that hold their color and stay fresh looking for a very long time. It seems to be constantly in bloom. Mine is just over 5 feet high. It's my favorite floribunda and one of my healthiest and most carefree plants.

    This year I am growing Kronprinzessin Viktoria that michaelg mentioned and can't comment much about her yet except to say that the flowers are exquisitely beautiful.

  • growing_rene2
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    oooh, so many great roses to choose from! I am very glad to know of the ones that are doing well in the area too! I might have to take out the pitiful pink unknown next to my white. :-) Thank you all so very much, the responses are above what I was expecting!! I sincerely appreciate all of your input & pictures.

  • the_morden_man
    10 years ago

    If you'd like to avoid diseases in general, then steer clear of the vast majority of Hybrid Teas.

    Michaelg gave you two really good choices in 'Kronprinzessin Viktoria' and 'Katerina Zeimet'. Another nice Polyantha is Marie Pavie.

    If I had to recommend a couple of whites, then they would be the shrub roses 'Escimo' and 'Kosmos Fairy Tale'. 'Petticoat Fairy Tale' is another very good creamy white rose. All three of these roses are hardy, vigorous, floriferous and exceptionally disease resistant.

  • frenchcuffs13
    10 years ago

    Sugar Moon.
    They have been very BS resistant here in rainy PNW and continue to bloom despite rain, holding the bloom for about a week on the plant. They bloom fairly continuously for a hybrid tea.I hear PJPII doesn't repeat well.?
    As far i know, any white will get spots if hit w/rain.

    OOOh and the scent is to die for (*got rave reviews at the recent rose show)

  • susan4952
    10 years ago

    Yum......O

  • seil zone 6b MI
    10 years ago

    Both PJPII and Garden Party are beautiful but will have to be sprayed to be BS and/or PM free. Garden Party will get to the wanted height of 6 ft. but it's doubtful that the Pope ever will. It's growth habit for me has been short and wide instead of tall and lanky like most HTs.

  • dan_keil_cr Keil
    10 years ago

    Pop[ Warner is a nice white. Moonstone is a white with pinkish blends, Pascali. I live 200 miles south of you in Decatur

  • mark_roeder 4B NE Iowa
    10 years ago

    Polarstern is a great white rose for our area. I think it is classified as a HT, but its form is more a Grandiflora with multiple roses, usually 5, per stem. The blooms are high-centered. It is nearly a continuous flowering rose bush.

    It grows to about 6' in our area. It has extraordinary hardiness for a rose this far north. It is scented. The bush is upright in form, which is what I prefer.

    My roses have been decimated in recent years by Japanese Beetles, and the whites are particularly susceptible, as they attract the beetles which then spread to the other bushes. If you are not inundated with JBs this is the best white I have seen with an upright form.

  • mark_roeder 4B NE Iowa
    10 years ago

    Polarstern a/k/a Polar Star a/k/a Evita.

    Apologies for lack of deadheading.

  • mark_roeder 4B NE Iowa
    10 years ago

    Polarstern

    Here is a link that might be useful: Polarstern on helpmefind

  • mark_roeder 4B NE Iowa
    10 years ago

    Polarstern see link. This is just what it looks like without my poor photographic effort:

    Here is a link that might be useful: Polarstern a/k/a Polar Star

  • cjrosaphile
    10 years ago

    My favorite white is Maria Shriver. Gorgeous grandiflora and the fragrance is heavenly. I did not like my PJPII -- it just wasn't vigorous. I owned Bolero and it did not do well for me either. This year, I added Winchester Cathedral after having Mary Rose for years and it doing well. We shall see. Good luck to you.

  • Himali
    10 years ago

    i am a rose lover. I added a new rose plant every year in my garden.My favorite white flower is Akito. It has a very goog fragnance and it looks very nice. i have this plant from last 3 years

  • taoseeker
    10 years ago

    My best white is Silver Anniversery (aka Karen Blixen). White flowers, healthy leaves and give lots of bloom. Flowers look very good too. Well worth checking out how it does in your area ;-)

  • alameda/zone 8/East Texas
    10 years ago

    I like the white Old Baylor - a Pioneer rose from the Antique Rose Emporioum - it stays healthy and blooms lots - a very tough rose.

    For my light colored roses, I like to spray some of that organic insecticidal spray on the buds to prevent thrips, which can turn a light colored rose brown.

    I have a young Pope Paul II that is quite healthy and has lovely blooms. If you want a climber, Lamarque is great.

  • racin_rose
    10 years ago

    I have a Kordes floribunda that's been excellent for me. It's from the "Fairytale" series and it's called Kosmos. It makes a big, frilly, old-fashioned type bloom that smells great and completely unlike any other rose I can recall. They start out tinged a flesh or blush color in the center and then fade to pure white, but last a long time.
    The plant itself is extremely healthy. It's really helping turn me into a Kordes fan. It doesn't have the "wow" factor of a perfectly formed white HT like PJP2, but I would highly recommend it.

  • growing_rene2
    Original Author
    10 years ago

    The Kordes floribunda is gorgeous! I have an area where I am only planting soft shades and this one will be perfect there. I will have to see how this one does in our area.
    The Evita is a beautiful rose, I will need to look in to this one as well...and all of the others that are just as perfect. This search of a perfect white is going to be harder than originally anticipated! LoL....thank goodness I have until next spring to research and decide!!

  • saldut
    10 years ago

    If your zone is warm enough, the Noisettes have lots of great no-spray whites, Champney's Pink Cluster never stops blooming and is large clusters, I have 2, they can get quite long...also Prosperity is a great white, ,also Rock Hill Peach,,,a great China is Ducher.... all these are no-spray...sally

  • susan4952
    10 years ago

    Fragrant Wave is also nice.

  • erasmus_gw
    10 years ago

    I like the hybrid musks Moonlight, a creamy white with good rebloom, Prosperity gets really big, repeats well, and Penelope. Penelope has apricot buds and can have a blush of pink or apricot that fades to white. For tiny blooms I like Lindee with dime sized blooms and good vigor. Makes a nice 3 or 4' shrub. Darlow's Enigma is a healthy, wild looking white. Lucille is a great bloomer, a small found rose with delicate, luminous blooms but bs prone. A friend gave me Sweet Afton , too early to say much. Another friend has Royal Highness , a mostly white ht with outstanding fragrance. I hear good things about Margaret Merril (sp?). I like the teas Angel's Camp Tea, mostly white, very fragrant with good rebloom. Also Madame Joseph Schwartz. I used to have Garden Party and liked it a lot..had pretty good bs resistance here, and bloomed very well. Moonstone is gorgeous. Martine Guillot is prolific, vigorous and healthy, mostly white.
    What about Secret's Out?

  • susan4952
    10 years ago

    My moonstone was soooo picky.

  • RD8005
    10 years ago

    Try 'Prairie Star' a Griffith J Buck shrub rose. Has a strong apple fragrance and holds up well to rain with some red spotting of the petals. It holds up well in dry conditions also. It is, like all white or light colored blooms, Japanese Beatle attractor if you are affected by them. It will last a long time after cut and in a vase and with debudding produces a nice flower. It is a constant bloomer and will produce flowers on a nice long stem with disbudding.
    I also have found success with HT Pascali.