Anyone grow less common Monarda types?

10 years ago

I have been enchanted with Monarda punctata this summer, not only for its stunningly architectural good looks but also for its health, long flowering season and ability to attract all sorts of fascinating insect pollinators in droves. Although said to be short-lived (planted this spring, I have not yet overwintered it), it is said to self-seed to perpetuate itself.

I also grow the more common Monarda 'Raspberry Wine'. While I LOVE the in-your-face, screaming, garden-dominating color of the blossoms, I have to admit that this plant is a dog. It is too tall for my needs, too lanky and brittle, spreads far too fast, and looks plain awful when finished blooming (2-3 weeks tops) is finished. It is relatively mildew resistant. All in all, I think this one will soon be shovel-pruned.

However, I enjoy monarda too much to give up on it entirely. Can anyone speak of their impressions and/or experiences with the following, or others I might have overlooked?:

Monarda bradburiana
Monarda 'Peter's Purple'
Monarda fistulosa 'Claire Grace'
Monarda fistulosa (Wichita Mountain Strain sold by High Country Gardens)
Rose-Scented Monarda (Monarda fistulosa tetraploid)
Monarda media
Monarda citriodora
Monarda 'Bryan Thompson'

I just obtained a small start of the rose-scented monarda from Companion Plants in Ohio, mainly to satisfy my curiosity. I was surprised to find that the leaves actually do have an intense scent of rose mixed in with just a bit of the bergamot odor.

This post was edited by ispahan on Mon, Aug 26, 13 at 23:05

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

aseedisapromise
10 years ago
I always have Monarda citriodora somewhere. Sometimes it has to be staked, but it is a pretty plant and doesn't mildew. Is an annual though, but easy to sow in place. It's blooming now here.
terrene
10 years ago
Nice patch of M citriodora Aseed! Love that plant. I grow some every year to put between the perennials but it sometimes gets floppy. Is yours in full sun and do you usually direct sow?

I grow M. punctata, and each plant usually lasts a couple years, and yes it does reseed around quite readily. I moved mine to the way back little meadow however, because it attracts an inordinate number of wasps, which are predators of my butterfly caterpillars! So it got banished. :)

I have a patch of M. bradburiana grown from seed - easy to do and this is a pretty and delicate Monarda that blooms about a month earlier than M. didyma cultivars. Reseeds a bit but not aggressive. Has nice foliage - not at all mildewy and is glossy with purply red tints.

I also have started M. fistulosa from seed, but moved that back to a wilder area, because of it's unruly habit - it would flop a lot, plus get some mildew. 'Claire Grace' is a terrific cultivar of M. fistulosa which doesn't flop at all for me, is bit more mildew-resistent, and clumps enlarge slowly. It does reseed a bit too. The M. fistulosa tetraploid sounds interesting.

While my noid Monarda didyma and 'Raspberry Wine' do indeed spread like crazy, and get terribly mildewy after bloom (especially this year it's super dry lately), I couldn't be without them. The hummingbirds and pollinators LOVE them!
Related Discussions
Common house plant that will grow fast outdoors?
Q
Comments (8)
Consider getting a Radermachera (common name is China Doll, I think), which is often available as a house plant at Lowes & HD. I've never been very successful with these indoors & wasn't especially pleased when I got one as a gift several years ago. I planted it among some perennials in a side garden, kind of expecting it to bite the dust fairly quickly. Not only did it grow like gang busters, it survived the winter here (lost its leaves, but came back strong in mid-spring). I've seen a wide variety of sizes -- from 4" pots to rather large containers. The plant I set out was about 18 inches tall, I'd guess. I took it out after it's third year . . . it wanted to be a tree. Loved the delicate, bright green foliage though. Incidentally, I saw a variegated form of this plant in Australia. Perhaps it will eventually be available here.
...See More
small, bush clematis types- does anyone grow them?
Q
Comments (18)
I tried googling to find out what varieties of clems do this & to what extent. I couldn't find hardly any info & the 1 link I did find was about propagating. It says: "There are a number of plants which have this habit, some that I have successfully divided to produce a few extra plants are; heracleifolia, cirhossa Balearica, the viorna section, integreifolia, ladakhiana, marmoraria, marata and some of the New Zealand hybrids, such as Little Runner." I'm with you, I can't have that going on in my yard either. I emailed someone on the China Purple that I know has experience with it & holding off on mine until I hear back. I can tell you how I handled a Wisteria issue that was like that if it would help? I'm not sure if they grow the same, but I did have a bunch of roots coming off the mother plant & sending up new plants 15' away, so it is similiar. If the roots are that thick, you will need a pruning saw (I did, the wisteria had been in the ground for at least 10 yrs). I removed as much dirt around the initial rootball as possible to find all the roots that had grown a million miles from it & started sawing & pruning them off until I could get the initial rootball out of the ground. I then sprayed round up on the freshly cut wounds of the stems still in the ground & left the dirt off of them for a good week for the sun to bake on them. It worked. I know round up isn't suppose to work like that, only on foliage, coincidence? I wasn't going to take the chance on putting nothing on them, I was literally having bad dreams about this plant not ever going away. You might want to sub for something a little more potent, but you may not be able to plant anything in that spot for a year. If it simply the case that they were living off the mother plant then severing them might have done the trick. Good luck!
...See More
will Asclepias syriaca/common milkweed grow in my area?
Q
Comments (9)
byrdlady, it's so good to hear this! where i grew up in western PA therew were syriaca grwing everywhere roadside, with nearly every patch having monarch colonies. now the milkweed is less common, because of more mowing, and monarchs are much less common, even up there. i've been trying to get syriaca going here, too. i have some nice patches of tuberosum after working on it for 8 or 9 yrs, and have grown currasvica from seed before. recently got some otherr ones (don't recall off the top), and just this yr, noticed 3 cats on my tuberosum. so maybe it does take a while for them to come. ralph gave me some potted currasavica, which i hope to overwinter in the cool basement, and some cats, too. hoping they'll come back in spring and lay eggs. the last one is making a chrysalis now. your expeience heartens me that i wasn't doing anything wrong. tammy
...See More
Is their a secret to growing Monarda?
Q
Comments (19)
If we analyse answers here, maybe we can get some trend - people who live in colder climates with well drained soil seem to have the best luck. (With the exception of those in BC, but those seem to be able to grow just about anything, sigh...) People living in hotter climates and less well drained soils seem not to be so lucky. Count me in as one of the unlucky ones. I started monarda for the first time last year from seed and even though they sprouted last year, this year the plant has simply vanished. I garden in a zone 10, warm, dry Mediterranean type of climate and I have clay soil. "From what I read they like well drained but moist soil." That is simply not going to happen for me - hardpan clay here at the moment, not even a shovel can be inserted into that soil! I have been adding compost over the years, but come August nothing can get in there... We just duck in and go to the beach instead... So, it looks like us in warmer climates will have to resign to live vicariously through gardeners in the colder zones that can enjoy these beauties. Eduarda
...See More
arbo_retum
10 years ago
i only grow Mahogany because of its deep maroon color.fun to learn about the others.
diggerdee zone 6 CT
10 years ago
I've grown citriodora for a few years - didn't start any this year. I really love the blooms and the bloom pattern on this.

I may go back to this next year, as I am sick and tired of trying to grow didyma - never does well for me and this year I discovered I had that horsemint moth worm. Eh!

The citriodora was nice and easy and looked great. Admittedly I've never tried any others, but I do love the citriodora.

Dee
river_crossroads z8b Central Louisiana
10 years ago
PeterÃ¢ÂÂs Purple is beautiful but I donÃ¢ÂÂt have full sun and it grows too tall and skinny at my place. Entirely the fault of my conditions, not the fault of the plant, I think. One of our many violent rainstorms will knock it over. I give it a haircut and it comes back but takes awhile to start blooming again.

Natural hybrid of 2 different native monarda created in the yard of Texas native plant expert and namesake Peter Loos. Nice smell like its M. fistulosa ancestor, but does not taste as good. Vibrant color that can stand up to Texas-size heat!

Anyone grow less common Monarda types?

Comments (5)

aseedisapromise

terrene

Related Discussions

arbo_retum

diggerdee zone 6 CT

river_crossroads z8b Central Louisiana

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US