mushroom soil smell

14 years ago

After replacing my septic field, I decided to landscape the whole area instead of replacing the grass. This is in the front of my house. I've never much liked grass. Anyway, I addressed my grading problems with screened top soil, which I was advised was the best thing to use. It doesn't however, seem to have much organic matter so I wanted to amend the soil, of course. I had mushroom soil delivered. It looks really rich and black, but it smells like tar. It doesn't smell like manure. I'm not concern about the fact that it smells. It's not that strong and I know that it will go away, especially after I've mulch. I'm thinking this might have something in it that I should worry about. Is this normal? This landscapers have already planted LOTS of stuff in this. How can I tell if this stuff is OK? Is there something I should add to it? Maybe I shouldn't worry.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

terran
14 years ago
I have loaded a lot of mushroom bedding over the years, and would never have characterized its scent, odor, or aroma as that of tar. My suggestion would be to find out where it came from and go visit if it isn't very far away. If nothing else call the mushroom grower and ask some questions about the medium that they use to grow the product and any amendments that might be used.

Terran
terran
14 years ago
I had another thought. Who hauled the Mushroom compost? If it was an independent hauler the previous material that was in the truck might have been asphalt.

Terran
Related Discussions
Mushroom smell
Q
Comments (3)
The odor of good, rich earth and that of "mushrooms" is very similar and both are an indication of a good, rich soil. I find many people have no idea what good, rich earth smells like today and when they rake up a pile of leaves in the spring and smell it they wonder what the problem is. They are more used to what soil that has been overfertilized smells like.
...See More
Mushroom smelling compost and...mites?
Q
Comments (4)
If the larva (bugs) of insects are living in your compost that most often means the compost pile is too wet to properly compost. A too wet compost pile excludes that air the aerobic bacteria also need to function and more often than not when I find a compost pile that has insect larva growing in it that compost also has a unpleasant odor indicating that anaerobic digestion is taking place. There is an old school of thought that says "stuff" for the garden should smell bad which is untrue. If something smells bad, offensive, disagreeable, it usually is. Compost should never smell of anything except good, healthy earth, a very pleasant odor.
...See More
Mushroom Soil - amendment or??
Q
Comments (22)
Cheryl, What MeMo is trying to say is that manure is best use shortly after full decomposition because by then the weeds it contains are dead. The seeds of weeds are ingested by the horses which passes through their guts undestroyed and so you will notice in fresh manure that seeds will germinate.. which is not good for soil amendment. So when the manure rots away, it produces heat hot enough to kill off these emerging weeds. (sometimes hot enough to cause spontaneous fires) Now after full decomposition, new weed seeds can resettle on the rotted manure and grow again because there'd be no heat. So in the case of manure older than 2 years, exposed outdoors, be careful that they do not contain weeds. You can do this early in the season by observing if any new seedlings grow and to break it up over severals days to kill off any germinating weeds. Ianna
...See More
Yellow mushrooms growing in soil
Q
Comments (2)
Not sure why my pictures didn’t upload... I didn’t save them either and scraped the mushrooms out. Maybe I overwatered when i repotted. Thanks for sharing your experience. I’ll wait it out and make sure it has lots of sun :)
...See More
jean001
14 years ago
Most likely it's not yet done composting.
Kimmsr
14 years ago
Even mushroom compost that is finished should smell like good, rich earth. Even if the truck that delivered the compost had hauled asphalt for 100 years that odor would not permeate the compost in that short a time. I don't know what you got but it is not something I would use, right now anyway.
freedee
Original Author
13 years ago
Bad news! It's more than a year later and there still is some of that smell, what's worse is that in areas where water has pooled a little, it is iridescent. Like oil from under a car.

There's no point in arguing with the supplier. What can Ido to counteract the problem?
sandhill_farms
13 years ago
"What can Ido to counteract the problem?"

I don't know if there's much you can do to "counteract" the problem as you don't know what it is. If it were me I would dig it all out, dispose of it, and start all over. I certainly wouldn't ever grow edibles in it, (not that you would).

Greg
Southern Nevada
Kimmsr
13 years ago
The solution used to mitigate some contaminated soils elsewhere is to add organic matter, shredded leaves, straw, whatever you can get a lot of for not much cost.
lisascenic Urban Gardener, Oakland CA
13 years ago
"There's no point in arguing with the supplier."

You can report them to the Better Business Bureau, and write a spicy review on Yelp.
retreatgal
11 years ago
I just purchased some mushroom compost which smell likes tar or oil. After doing some searching it seems that one reason for the dreadful coal tar smell is cresol. Cresol is created when organic substances break down and some types of fungi also smell like coal tar as well.

At low levels there is no evidence it causes any problem but if you breath in high concentrations it can make your eyes and throat sore. At really high levels you can actually pass out. Not enough research has been done on this substance.

Some info on naturally occurring and manufactured cresols can be found in this PDF - http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxguides/toxguide-34.pdf

It seems to break down readily in soil and via the action of microbes. It doesn't accumulate in the body and is excreted in urine. It can be absorbed orally, through the lungs and skin.

Can't say I am very happy about the smell. I previously purchase mushroom compost and it just had a musty earthy smell so this tar smell is quite unexpected. Won't be buying it again though unless I smell it first.

You have to uncover the pile to smell it because I was kicking it around with my boot prior to purchasing it and couldn't smell it until after it was scooped up and put into the trailer. Peeeuuuuw. I think for safety's sake it would be wiser not to use any compost that smells like this.
Rich_PNW
11 years ago
I've had a lot of mushroom compost smell that way. Still has the same wonderful results and I'm not dead yet. I'm sure it is known to cause cancer in the state of California, but I live in Washington so I'm safe ;-)
piedmontnc
11 years ago
You shouldnt be landscaping over a septic field, grass cover is best for wastewater treatment
toxcrusadr
11 years ago
It sounds like a temporary condition and I suspect it's related to the substrate (what type of wood, etc. went into the mix) as well as the presence of certain types of fungi or other microbes. So it doesn't happen all the time, just when the conditions are right.

Sheen on the water can be organic matter from the composting process. I've seen rainbows on the water from sawdust piles, big mulch piles and decaying leaf piles. Without chemical analysis it's impossible to pin it on anything specific.