Scotts Miracle Gro company is knowingly poisoning birds

12 years ago

I learned of this story from Doug Green the Gardener.

It turns out that Scotts Miracle Gro lawn and garden company has been producing bird seed that is coated with a pesticide that prevents it from being eaten by insects during transport. The problem is that the coating is poisonous to birds-ya, know, the intended recipients of the food??? And what is worse, when employees told them the coating is poisonous they not only did nothing about it, they covered it up when the EPA tried to investigate.

Read the story here:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/grrlscientist/2012/mar/21/2

THEY PLEAD GUILTY TO KNOWINGLY ADDING BIRD-KILLING PESTICIDES TO BIRD FOOD!!!

Our wild bird and song bird populations have been dwindling, and people are trying to help by providing food for these creatures. I am sickened at the thought that those who have been trying to help were inadvertently harming and possibly killing the very animals they were trying to save, all because of corporate greed.

I don't know about you, but I am throwing out any and all Scotts products we have, and writing them a letter that their actions are despicable, and they have lost me as a customer. This includes never using Miracle Gro potting soil or fertilizer, their Step program lawn care products, any hardware such as spreaders or dispensers.

I post this here because so many people use Miracle Gro potting soil for their seeds.

Decide if you want to support this kind of corporate behavior. If you do, keep on buying their products. If you don't, then buy from a different company, and when you do, tell your supplier why you're making that decision.

Beatrice

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

terrene
12 years ago
I had heard about this awhile back. I am an avid backyard bird-watcher, participate in bird counts, etc. I feed a little suet and sunflower seed, but primarily focus on creating habitat for the birds in my yard with lots of native plants and lots of bugs for them to eat.

Looking at the big picture, birds have much bigger problems than some poisoned bird seed. Habitat destruction is the #1 cause of the decline of bird populations. #2 is collisions with human structures - buildings, windows, etc. which kills up to 1 billion birds per year. The human race is not very good about co-existing and respecting other species on this planet.
bakemom_gw
12 years ago
This is not the proper forum for this type of discussion.
Related Discussions
SCOTTS 'Nature Scapes' Sierra Red dyed mulch
Q
Comments (3)
This company is not a good company for organic gardeners to patronize because they are not eco friendly. The USEPA banned the sale of wood, and wood products, that contain CCA several years ago. Since that "mulch" is considered a non hazardous product no MSDS is needed and the one copied here is a very general one that covers a wide range of other products manfactured by this not at all eco friendly company.
...See More
Scotts Company
Q
Comments (44)
So while I was looking up a link about the evilness of Walmart (see http://www.intellectualpoison.com/WalMartisPureEvil.html ) I came across an interesting link about Monsanto and thought it would relate to this discussion a little bit. See below. As for why Walmart employees stay, it sure isn't for the pay or benefits. Maybe most of the other businesses in their towns went under? All the Jewel grocery stores in WI closed this year, they paid well and had health benefits, oh well, couldn't compete with evil Walmart I suppose. Christine, I don't think you understood me. I am on a Linux system, NOT Microsoft. We were also sent new, free Microsoft software, which is installed on one partition of our computer. We mainly only run Microsoft when running our TurboTax software, to post items on Ebay (TurboLister doesn't run on Linux) and to play pinball, which means we are running Linux 99% of the time. It is nice to have a computer that just runs and runs and runs, no blue screen of death. Marcia Here is a link that might be useful: Brazilian farmers storm Monsanto
...See More
Does Miracle Gro Kill Worms?
Q
Comments (32)
Scarlettblue, If you don't have a use for leftover chemical fertilizer, and don't personally know anyone who would like to have it, here's what to do: you should find out what your municipality does about Household Hazardous Waste collection. Often times there are mobile collection events for HHW as well as central locations where you can drop stuff off. In the last two cities I've lived in they have had the mobile events, and if one is held near you, they are very handy - they set everything up in a parking lot somewhere on a weekend, you put the stuff you want to get rid of in your trunk, and they take it out for you - done. Please DON'T put such items as chemical fertilizers, pesticides, and herbicides in the household trash. Your local government doesn't want that stuff going in the landfill any more than you do. That's why they provide specialized collection and disposal services for it. Even more so, DON'T flush it down the house drains. And not that you would do this, but NEVER EVER EVER dump it into a storm drain, because that WILL put the stuff right into the local waterways by the most direct possible route. Just to give a typical example, here is the listing of items that my city treats as Household Hazardous Waste: http://www.philadelphiastreets.com/hazardous-waste Paint and Paint Related Materials Solvent-based paints and stains Paint thinner Varnish Paint stripper and paint brush cleaners (NOTE: Latex paint is not hazardous.) Lawn and Garden Products and Outdoor Products Pesticides (fungicides, herbicides, insecticides, rodenticides) Chemical fertilizers Grill type propane cylinders (up to 20 lbs.) Swimming pool chemicals Kitchen, Bathroom Products and Cleaning Solvents Cleaning solvents Fire Extinguishers Aerosol cans Bathroom and tile cleaner Toilet bowl cleaner Oven cleaners Drain cleaners Automotive Products Used motor oil Antifreeze Lead-acid batteries Auto body repair products Brake fluid Degreasers Flammable Materials Kerosene Old gasoline Other Materials Fluorescent Light Tubes (transport in original box if possible) and Compact Fluorescent Lights (CFL) PCBs Dioxin forming compounds Mercury Asbestos (Non-Friable Only) for Information on proper asbestos removal, go to City of Philadelphia Health Department's web site Artists' paints Photographic chemicals Lead products, including solder, fishing weights, and similar items Household Batteries Rechargeable computer and cell phone batteries Button cell batteries used for hearing aids, watches, and calculators (NOTE: Household batteries size D, C, AA, AAA and 9 volt are not considered hazardous.) Other Household Products Moth balls Stain and spot removers
...See More
Something that you may not know about Scott's
Q
Comments (15)
I make my own suet cakes. Below is a recipe that one of our bird rehabbers uses so I thought I would share it here. It is almost identical to what I use and compared to commercial suet cakes costs pennies to make. I keep mine in the freezer and take them out as needed. I press the mixture into rubbermade sandwich keepers or if you have the plastic trays that the commercial stuff comes in you can use that as a mold and after you freeze the 'dough' just pop it out of the mold and wrap in plastic wrap or put in sandwhich bagss until needed. --A 2 lb bag of yellow corn meal --About 2 large, heaping serving spoons of peanut butter --About 4 large heaping serving spoons of vegetable shortening --(We add avian vitamins only because we have them, nice but not necessary). Mix thoroughly and adjust ingredients as necessary to make the consistency of a soft sugar cookie dough.
...See More
caryltoo Z7/SE PA
12 years ago
Why is it not the proper forum? I'd like to know if I'm poisoning birds and might not see it elsewhere.
morz8 - Washington Coast
12 years ago
Old news, the products in question were recalled in 2008. The only thing new is the legal finalizing and paying of the fine last month. Let this move away, or move over to conversations where it should have been placed....
ladyrose65
12 years ago
I agree with Terrene. We are brick and mortaring everything! The "Lorax" movie needs to be broadcasted on national TV!
wantie
12 years ago
I didn't know about this before.

And would not have if I hadn't read it here, now.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------.

If they did it then--- what else are they up to??????????
auntyara
12 years ago
this is another forum where such things are discussed.and many more
:) Laura

Here is a link that might be useful: hot topics forum
ellenrr
12 years ago
thanks Beatrice,
I hadn't known of this before. Altho I never buy Scott's products.
As to where this is placed, everyone has the ability to follow or not any thread.
There are plenty of threads on here which are not directly related to WS: people's children, a nice event, a sad event, etc. Lots and lots. Which is fine with me.

If I am not interested I don't read it.
I don't demand that it not be here.

Live and let live.
trudi_d
12 years ago
This is the WRONG FORUM for this post. I don't know why you posted this at Winter Sowing when you can get a much larger audience at Hot Topics here at GW or any other ranting venue on the internet.
terrene
12 years ago
Probably because many people use Miracle gro products to winter-sow?

Repeatedly chastising people about what they post here is not doing this forum any favors. JMO.
auntyara
12 years ago
Hi I sure hope no one thinks I was trying to say you can't discuss anything you like in any forum, I was just sharing a link to another forum with lots of info on lots of topics.

sorry if any one thought I was trying to say that you can't post information here. I personally think it was good to inform us about Scotts products here. Like terrene has stated many of us do use their products.
:) Laura
trudi_d
12 years ago
Personally, people can use whatever they want to sow their seed. GW has a huge array of forums where you can discuss in length this, that or the other thing. At WS, if your post is about sowing and growing, seeds and seedlings, dealing with people's reactions to WS, and anything else related to WS and the seedlings it produces then gab away. Just my personal opinion, but edgy posts should go to Hot Topics where you'll find a lot more people to dialogue with about whatever it is that irks.

Scotts Miracle Gro company is knowingly poisoning birds

Comments (12)

terrene

bakemom_gw

Related Discussions

caryltoo Z7/SE PA

morz8 - Washington Coast

ladyrose65

wantie

auntyara

ellenrr

trudi_d

terrene

auntyara

trudi_d

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US