Birch tree advice, and other madness.

14 years ago

I'm considering Whitespire birch and Dura-Heat River Birch trees. I got the idea for the Whitespire by reading that it is birch borer resistant. Also, my girlfriend is of Russian and New Hampshire background, and likes white birches. I recently saw that New Hampshire is covered with white birches, probably paper birches, right?. They look impressive, but I keep reading about the borer. As for the Dura Heat River Birches, I know they aren't white, but reports seem to suggest dense leaves, which I like. For either, I'm considering buying them from a mail order outfit "FF" on the upper West Coast that has done well for me in the past. With shipping and handling, a 5-6 foot tree runs me around $106. If I go the nursery route, it would probably be a generic river birch or white barked himalayan birch for about $220. These trees would be real trees, around 15 feet tall, while the sticks from FF won't look like trees for awhile. Any advice on these trees? Are clumps or single trees a better approach?

Let me also mention the situation just for fun. Last October, a 100 foot plus Norway maple street tree was taken down by the city due to losing a limb in a windstorm. While the limb didn't fall on my property, they dumped the tree square on my land, ripping my European Hornbeam tree in half and also badly damaging a Forest Pansy Redbud. When the dust settled, the right side of my property became a disaster area. I managed to get a pittance back from the city, and have my work cut out for me now. On a positive note, I now have more sun for whatever I plant.

Thanks for your advice!

Comments (5)

mainegrower
14 years ago
In general, birches do much better in cold climates than in warm ones. If you have lots of summer days in the upper 80's/90's with warm nights, most birches will struggle and be even less long lived than this genus is naturally.

I'm sure you would be able to find named birch cultivars at nurseries near you. The West Coast mailorder company you mention is one of the best, but it does seem a little strange to ship something across the entire country when it's available locally. Whether single tree or clump is entirely a matter of personal taste.
iforgotitsonevermind
14 years ago
Jacquemonti birch is the common garden variety white/silver leaved birch. Trudy will love it.
Related Discussions
Anyone on here ever grow River Birch trees from seed?
Q
Comments (8)
I too love birches and would love a little wood of them. I would plant Scottish bluebells under them en mass. A seed trading friend of mine in California sent me three bags of birch seeds (besides the ones I got myself from the little tree at Lowe's). They are European Birch, White American Paper Birch and one other that I cannot recall off hand. I read that they had to be fresh or they wouldn't grow, so I didn't planted them. But now, I think I will go ahead and try sprouting them. What have I got to lose? I think if I put them in very soggy paper towels and stick them in plastic bags, they should sprout, as that is where they sprout best in their natural environment - on the banks of brooks and rivers where it is very wet. Worth a try. Eduarda, I appreciate your input. Muito Obrigada! ~Annie
...See More
Planting around established Birch trees
Q
Comments (1)
don't know about your area, but here the main cause of death of trees is being planted (buried) too deeply. I'd say you need expert local advice; county agricultural extension agent or local gardening clubs or Arbor day Society or some such. Although all plant roots compete for nutrients & water, & although planting anything under a tree involves at least some disturbance of the roots, healthy established trees can usually look after themselves. You might try shallow-rooted ground covers such as ivy (a variety that you can either control or that doesn't tend to strangle trees) to keep things as simple as possible
...See More
Backsplash Advice - Red Birch, White and Granite
Q
Comments (7)
Thanks avidinternet and others for your posts. I spent many hours over the last days staring and thinking. Thanks for the support that most of the options would work. The recommendation to keep to three colors has been very helpful. I was trying paint colors with slight yellow and green tones and feeling that they were not quite right. Now I realize that the real color focus is the birch cabinets (duh..) So, based on reading this post and many others, I went back to my inspirational photos (so GW :) The backsplashes sometimes introduce a new color, but work when they also pick up on at least one, often two of the main colors of the rest of the kitchen. For example, painted white and natural red birch cabinets with black countertops and a sparkly mosaic backsplash that picks up the cabinet tone, is reflective like the white and brings in a green, which is then used for a wall color. My challenge is with two different counters (though both are gray) I have to careful, especially with the movement of the island (the head cheese comment made me laugh :) Color wise, I am leaning towards BM Revere Pewter for the walls, more of a light gray/putty with a very slight green undertone but not a "color" like the others. Backsplash wise, it is either some calcatta (mosaic - hand cut or not, mini-brick or 2x4 brick) but need to determine if more white like the Statuary Calcutta, more color (Calcatta Tia) or in between (Calcatta Med brick.) I still have a soft spot for the Sand Chelsea art glass and love the triangle glass mosaic, but (1) I fear is is less "natural" then everything else I have chosen and (2) it is ridiculously priced. I have included a link to the same backsplash album, but the last two photos show the paint colors and tile colors options I am leaning toward (colorful Calcatta Tia and less colorful Calcatta), not necessarily the format of tile (yes, I think the flat octagons are too much, but I love that tile :) I did not have a sample of the more white calcatta staturario. Does anyone have thoughts on polishes versus honed on the walls? The Pietra countertops are honed and the Super White island is polished (for now, though we may change.) Thanks again for the direction, any other input appreciated. Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen Backsplash Options with Paint colors at end
...See More
Cabin- skyscraper trees fallin' like mad, what to do?
Q
Comments (16)
As for mulch... leaves (wet or dry) ARE mulch. For the health of the forest, leaves make a much better mulch than wood chips. Wood chips make good mulch in certain areas, but I'm not sure what purpose they would serve in a wooded area. And, if you spread wood chips, it will be that much harder to deal with next year's leaves because they'll be on wood chips and whether you rake, or blow, wood chips will go everywhere. So... the question remains... why remove the leaves? Like I said, if you're just going for a certain look, that's your choice... but for far longer than any human has walked this Earth, trees have been doing quite well using leaves as mulch. I use wood chips as mulch in the paths of my garden. For that purpose, they are fantastic. Leaves, though, are the mulch I use on the garden beds for the winter. They are far more beneficial for the ground than wood chips. Watch the birds. Especially during nesting season, they will flip leaves around to find insects to feed their young. Why? Because leaves give a natural home to the life of the forest floor. And that is the health of the forest. If you do chip some of that wood, then sure, put it where you want, but you don't have to remove the leaves unless you see them as unsightly. You could just add the chips to the leaves. The only reason that people remove leaves from lawns is because they want the look of the planting. Leaves can smother some plantings, but generally, it's a cosmetic thing. In fact, the healthiest of lawns are those where the leaves are mulched in place - allowing them to feed the soil web. It comes down to why you want to do something. Just reading that wood chips make good mulch does not mean they are better for the trees than leaves. It's very difficult to do better than nature. You can manipulate your land as you want, but for the long-term health of the trees and the forest, you just cannot beat leaves. Like I said above... by all means, create a safe space for you and your family, but trees fall all the time. A fallen tree can even help with soil runoff - making a barrier to protect the forest floor. They host all kinds of beneficial organisms. I have lots of fireflies here. Their larvae live under decaying wood and eat all manner of pest. If there's nothing to be hurt, I would let things happen naturally. Personally, I see no reason to remove fallen trees unless they are in the way of something relatively important, but perhaps that's just me.
...See More
suel41452
14 years ago
Jacquemontis are gorgeous, but highly susceptible to BBBorers. I've noticed quite a few in front lawns here that have croaked after about 10 yrs. or so.
I bought a "Renci" birch - because it's supposed to be less susceptible to BBBs - as a 3ft. baby at this link:
http://www.advancedtree.com/tree_paperbirch.htm
It's been real healthy so far, and the bark (tree's at 12 ft. now) is super white.
. I've read generic river birches drop a lot of stuff; twigs, etc., - supposedly Heritage RBs don't.
I apply Bayer's Tree and Shrub soil drench (you only apply it once a year) to my birches. It is a systemic insecticide that is supposed to kill BBBs, Birch leafminers, adult Japanese beetles, and a host of other pests.
adrian_monk2
Original Author
14 years ago
Went to the nursery today and saw one Jacquemonti that might work somewhere for me. The thing is, Trudy also says she likes "black spots" on her birches. This tree is pretty much all white. I think it looks good though, but approval will be needed.

aside- We went a little crazy last year planting "sticks" after the incident, including a tiny Whitespire birch and Size 5 American Hornbeam. There was a sense of imbalance with the street tree gone that had dominated the right side of the lawn. The 5 foot stick helped a little, but I'm thinking I need real trees now. It's a bit of a messy stick jungle now.

Anyway, decided today to replace the decimated European Hornbeam with another one at the nursery that looked up to the job.
I need the screening from the neighbors across the street who built a porch facing my front door. It gets complicated beyond that. The forest pansy took a major hit to the central leader, but still appears to be a viable tree after the broken section was pruned off. The thing is, the red leaves in June kind of blended into my brownish house, and it didn't seem to work in this prime spot as I thought. I am tempted to move it somewhere and put a jaquemonti (if approved) or some other birch there. I get a lot of resistance when talking about moving things, "just let it be..plant around it.. blah, blah", but that has a way of preventing definitive action :)
arbordave (SE MI)
14 years ago
Sue from VA is correct - jacquemonti birch is definitely susceptible to borers and should be avoided. Renci (= Renaissance Reflection) does have white bark and is borer resistant, but is not widely available.

Whitespire is also susceptible to borers.

If you opt for river birch, be sure to get Dura-Heat or one of the other improved varieties (Heritage, City Slicker).

Birch tree advice, and other madness.

Comments (5)

mainegrower

iforgotitsonevermind

Related Discussions

suel41452

adrian_monk2
Original Author

arbordave (SE MI)

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Birch tree advice, and other madness.

Comments (5)

mainegrower

iforgotitsonevermind

Related Discussions

suel41452

adrian_monk2Original Author

arbordave (SE MI)

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

adrian_monk2
Original Author