EarthKind in Texas; All Stars in California

10 years ago

Jackie wondered if California had an equivalent program to Texas's EarthKind program for roses. I'm posting the reply here for greater visibility.

While California does not participate in the EarthKind program, and does not have a rose-specific program, UC Davis does have a program called the Arboretum All Stars. To quote from their website:

"The horticultural staff of the UC Davis Arboretum have identified 100 tough, reliable plants that have been tested in the Arboretum, are easy to grow, don't need a lot of water, have few problems with pests or diseases, and have outstanding qualities in the garden. Many of them are California native plants and support native birds and insects. Most All-Star plants can be successfully planted and grown throughout California."

Four roses have been included in the 100 plants. They are Iceberg, Mutabilis, Perle d'Or, and Pink Gruss an Aachen.

UC Davis is hosting a Rose Day on May 5th. It seems to be centered around their All American Test Garden. I won't be there since I am busy that day. UC Davis does have one of the few (two?) rose virus indexing programs in the United States. Given that California is a center of the rose breeding and rose growing industry, I think the focus is on there, and understandably so.

http://ccuh.ucdavis.edu/events/roses-2012/your-sustainable-backyard-roses

Rosefolly

Here is a link that might be useful: UC Davis Arboretum All Stars

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

jerijen
10 years ago
It's interesting to note that while not all Earthkind Roses are "all-stars" in California, I certainly have found all four of these to be.
I'd love to see more roses meet Davis's criteria. I know many can.
jacqueline9CA
10 years ago
Thanks for the info! These 4 roses certainly are good in CA - I agree with Jeri that I hope they do more roses. Interesting that these are chinas & polyanthas - hope next time they test some tea roses!

Jackie
Related Discussions
Yellow Rose of Texas
Q
Comments (21)
Thanks so much for all of the input! My hubby's interest in the yellow rose of texas comes from his sister. They are army brats and that is where she was born. The family is from Missouri, so it just came up in conversation and he thought it would be nice. I told him what you all said...Harisons rose, the fact that I should pick one and call it that. He thought that was so funny. He actually called you all enablers! LOL But he truely believes that there is an actual rose, so it will take a bit of doing to get around all of this, because he thinks he can find it on the web. Silly Man! I do have several yellows in my garden, Graham Thomas, Golden Celebration, Yellow Charles Austin, Lovely Child, Breden, Pat Austin and Carefree Sunshine. I have about 20 roses so far, with 3 more on the way. What is so funny is that he brought home 2 Falstaffs from Walmart on friday.(Body bags) He knew they were Austins and thought I could "save" them. Half price and all. So, after all the rain this weekend, I will be off to the garden around 11 to find spots for 2 reds I hadn't planned on. I have about a 8 ft. section of fencing when you pull up to the house that could use a couple of roses....only thing is, now I need a white to go in between the 2 reds! LOL He actually bought that, and said to order it. It's like taking candy from a baby~ LOL!!! Thanks again to everyone! Mary
...See More
California gold
Q
Comments (14)
Hi all. I have a CA Gold from Jeff Earl that I went to Modesto to pick up in person. I found Jeff to be a very nice host and very proud of his CA Gold bananas. He has a small plantation of about a dozen plants, and can prolly sell only about 6-12 pups a year. They grow about 5-7 ft tall at the top of the P-stem, with 3' long leaves. He is not in it for the money, or these would be selling for what an AEAE sells for, TC'd, (or he would have many more mother plants to pull pups from). He just wants to share this particular variant so it'll be preserved thru diversity and geography. The descriptions of the plant are his own and he states just that in his ads, along with the history of his original plant as he knows it. I have seen the conditions he grows in and these are not wrapped up and protected thru the winters. They are left to their own and do very well. They are not fawned over or babied. He provides them with loose Modesto dirt (of a clay like nature, not blended mixes), plenty of water and ferts, and an occasional pruning and pup removal. The rest is up to the plants. Whether the history is accurate or not is debatable and can never be proven short of a dna map, but the authenticity of his claims to it being very cold hardy are true. I am growing a CA Gold, a Dw. Orinoco, and Manzano. I will need some time to tell if they are the same, similar, or completly different. I'll post my personal findings on the forum in the future, but for now, I'd be happy to get just a single bunch of bananas from any of my plants. Tell me I don't have to wait for next year... Just my 2 cents...not affiliated with Jeff Earl (other than a couple emails and a visit to pick up my pup) nor do I get a kickback for every plant sold...yada...blah de blah blah... Only the first name is similar... Thanks for listening... Jeff (Conestogaman) Soucek
...See More
2007 Texas Gardening Events
Q
Comments (1)
bumpety bump!
...See More
new to Texas....
Q
Comments (11)
Hi there--you will love gardening in Austin... there are so many cool local nurseries and resources that are really tailored to our climate and especially native plants. We are very blessed to have so many unique places to buy garden things... and the people who work at the locally-based nurseries here are always very helpful about what will work or not work. And of course the Ladybird Johnson Wildflower Center is here, which is really a national treasure. It has both wild and formal wildflower and native plant gardens and is a great way to see the different seasons of growth in this area (or the seasons of wildflower bloom in TX). The cool thing about Austin is that it pretty much sits on a fault line which divides it into two completely different climates... types of soils... there are challenges and joys in both--I garden on the Austin clay. It can actually be quite fertile.. and the right native plants grow in it. It just often needs amendments to get it more 'plantable' and less dense. I think what's really hard about it is that it's hard to dig when it's dry, but lots of plants and trees are perfectly happy in the clay, even some of my roses. When you get here look for The Garden Guide for Austin - which is put together by the county gardeners and has a great planting schedule for plants we can grow here as well as suggested resources.... (there's stuff on wildflowers in there, too). Also, most nurseries here carry a small booklet called "Grow Green" which is a very good start to what native and adapted plants do well here. Cseim mentioned it above, and you can download or search this guide from the city's website: Grow Green have fun discovering!
...See More
eahamel
10 years ago
Here's a list of the Texas Earthkind roses.

I'm sure you'll find a lot of familiar faces here! Since most of these are well-known antiques and a few moderns, I don't know why most wouldn't do well in CA.

Here is a link that might be useful: Texas Earthkind Roses List
kristimama
10 years ago
In addition to that list, 2 additional roses (Monsieur Tillier and Mrs. Dudley Cross) were added to the EarthKind List in 2011.
http://aggie-horticulture.tamu.edu/newsletters/hortupdate/2011/apr/ek-roses-2011.html

This is an interesting discussion. I guess in my naivete about roses, I sort of assumed that the EarthKind roses were a good list of drought tolerant roses that would work in a variety of climates even outside of California. But I guess I should have paid more attention to the fact that it's part of the Texas University system and maybe not all will work for California. It's great that UC Davis has a list, albeit a short one. I wonder if someone from the Heritage Roses groups in California has spoken with the folks from UCD to lobby for the inclusion of some of the heartier antique roses in California?
jerijen
10 years ago
eahamel -- I've found through direct experience that no-few "Earthkind" roses have tremendous rust and/or mildew problems in my conditions.

The fungal issue of importance to their testing is blackspot.

Roses that are blackspot resistant in Texas FREQUENTLY turn out to rust and/or mildew badly in my garden.
Moreover, many roses that are disease-free in the Central Valley have TERRIBLE problems here at the coast.

That being so, for me, an "Earthkind" title is of academic interest only, and even tests at Davis mean little to me.

We go back to "Location, Location, Location."

Jeri

EarthKind in Texas; All Stars in California

Comments (5)

jerijen

jacqueline9CA

Related Discussions

eahamel

kristimama

jerijen

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US