Question about 'blender' composting

16 years ago

My first visit here as well. I'd like to ask about a method I read in a "green tips" booklet about kitchen waste. Basically, you just stuff a blender with your kitchen scraps, (eggshells, coffee grounds, teabags, vegetable waste), add a cup of water when full, blend it up, then take it outside and dump on your beds.

I'm constantly battling with fruit flies hovering over my kitchen compost bucket, whereas the rubber top of the blender seals the container until you have enough to whip up.

It's fun to do, but I wonder if adding this raw "soup" to my beds would be beneficial.

Featured Answer

shellva

16 years ago

Good gosh Wendy, whatever you are doing it works! Beautiful!

The tea would be a green, the paper of the tea bag a brown, I would think. I don't see what you are wanting to do as a bad thing. No matter how you look at it, you are adding organic material to your beds, period.

I have a compost pile cooking and it is doing fine (mine is right off the deck at the backdoor, only a few steps of walking required). So now instead of always dumping my kitchen pail into the pile, I am walking out to the garden (my version of walking to the back40, aaahhh the irony of it all!), digging a hole where I know I am planting each tomato in the spring and burying the mainly nitrogen type kichen waste. I say mostly nitrogen because there are some coffee filters and tea bags in each dump. I'm looking at what I am doing as an experiment. And it's an excuse to play in the dirt in January;)

Could your kitchen waste be put to a better use, maybe, but in the end it's not going to the landfill and your soil is still going to get use of it. You just don't have to walk to the back 40.

I'll see you in the wintersowing forum.

Michelle

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (70)

flora_uk
16 years ago
Where does the 3 minutes a week come from? My kitchen generates about 4 buckets of compostable waste per week. My blender takes about 1 1/2 pints. It's impractical and pointless.
tibs
16 years ago
I want to move to Wendy's town. The city takes her garden stuff away and brings back finished mulch? Wow.
Related Discussions
Question about adding "compost"
Q
Comments (5)
Chicken manure is a most nitrogen rich one. I wouldn't put it directly in the garden for few reasons. Nitrogen goes away fast. Added to soil in fall, it will be almost gone by spring. So it is kind of waste of good nitrogen. But what it can actually do, it can help to compost a lot of carbon materials to create organic matter. You soil needs good organics probably more then nitrogen itself. So I second shayneca25 - compost it. If turning it every week seems too much of work - you can leave it as is, it will take about a year to decompose. What also you can do - you can dry some of the staff, better without wood. In summer you can dissolve it in water(Google the proportions!) and use as a great organic fertilizer.
...See More
Question About Composting Silky Oak, Pine Needles and Juniper.
Q
Comments (11)
FYI.... seems to very much depend on the % of HCN... I dont know much about it, but some interesting reading... --------------------- ----------------------- EFFECT ON PLANT LIFE Seeds HCN applied in dosages effective ageinst insects does not affect the viability of seeds that are normally dry, with moisture contents suitable for storage. In a comprehensive study, the results of which were published between 1959 and 1961, Strong and Lindgren studied the effect of HCN in insecticidal concentrations on the germination of a wide range of seeds, including grain seeds, flax and small legumes. The variable factors considered were moisture content (8 to 14 percent), repeat fumigations and postfumigation storage. It wes concluded that germination of wheat, barley, oats, rice and flax seeds wes not impaired by one or two famigations with HCN. With the small legumes with a range of 5.8 to 12.2 percent moisture content (Ranger alfalfa, alsike clover, Ladino clover, Kenland red clever and Viking birdsfoot trefoil), all were tolerant to HCN in one or two fumigations, except aisike clover for which there was positive indication of impairment of germination. Among 80 varieties of grain, vegetable and flower seeds tested by Lindgren et al (1955), six showed evidence of reduced germination. These were pole beans, burnet, California black mustard, smilo, marigold and snapdragon. It may be concluded that HCN is a safe fumigant to use for seed treatment, especially for cereal grains under normal conditions, but with flower and vegetable seeds preliminary trials with local varieties are advisable. Growing Plants and Trees A considerable amount of injury, either temporary or permanent, may be sustained by actively growing plants fumigated with HCN. Because this gas is very soluble in water, special precautions have to be taken to reduce the amount of moisture on leaves and stems and in pots or soil balls of actively growing plants. Therefore, the plants should not be watered for one or more days before treatment. After treatment with HCN, it is necessary to wash the plants with water to remove any residual acid. HCN interferes with photosynthesis and other physiological processes (Moore and Willaman, 1917); for that reason, plants may be more susceptible to injury in daylight. Usually, treatments have to be carried out at night or in the dark. Also, following exposure, plants should be kept away from sunlight for several hours. In the past HCN was widely used for fumigating ornamental and glasshouse plants, but it has been replaced by other fumigants that are less phytotoxic. The use of HCN generated from calcium cyanide to control glasshouse pests is discussed in Chapter 12. HCN was extensively used for may years to control scale insects on citrus trees in a tent fumigation procedure (Quayle, 1938). In this treatment, HCN gas (5 g/m ) from liquid HCN, or evolved from a salt such as calcium cyanide, was liberated into a relatively gas-tight tent installed over the tree and maintained for usually around 45 mintues. A number of factors, including temperature, humidity, physiological conditions of the tree (such as dormancy, disease, cultural conditions, stage of development and others), have considerable influence on the tolerance of the trees to the fumigant (Woglum, 1923). Since different species or varieties of citrus trees show wide variation in response and the insects in different areas may vary in tolerance, the actual conditions of treatment usually have to be developed to suit local circumstances. In scale insect eradication work, where complete kill of all insects is essential, the tent fumigation treatment with HCN has been found to be a valuable technique (Fosen et al, 1953). HCN was used by Del Rivero et al, (1974) to control larvae and eggs of the woolly white fly on orange trees. While the concentrations of HCN required to kill insects may cause severe injury to growing plants, lower concentrations of HCN may stimulate growth and be useful in "forcing" growth in some species (Gassner, 1925). Dormant Nursery Stock HCN is still used in many parts of the world for the fumigation of the dormant nursery stock of deciduous trees, especially in quarantine treatments against the spread of scale insects (Ceder and Mathys, 1949; van de Pol and Rauws, 1957; Agarwala, 1956; Jen and Lai, 1959). As in growing plants, a marked stimulation has been noticed in some nursery stock fumigated with HCN (Cassner, 1925). Immediately following fumigation it is sometimes necessary to wash plants with water to avoid the burning of buds and new foliage. ---------- Cyanide production by rhizobacteria and potential for suppression of weed seedling growth. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11400067 Here is a link that might be useful: Cyanide production by rhizobacteria and potential for suppression of weed seedling growth.
...See More
Question about length of time to compost
Q
Comments (16)
I have 3 compost piles going. I reinforced one with 25ft of 1/2" hardware cloth to keep any rodents out. 25ft was enuff to go 3x3 and line the bottom and make a cover. I use it for the kitchen scraps and have not had a problem since. In another pile I compost just weeds and lawn trimmings. No kitchen scraps. And contrary to what some here believe composting just greens will heat up nicely when you add just the right amount of water. In the past I would add kitchen scraps to the center of a hot pile w/o any rodent problems. The reason to get the pile hot is not only to make compost faster but to kill the weed seeds. I am sure you will be harvesting weeds on 35 acres. This time of year they come with seeds as will anything from a tree service. They grind up ivy, sumac, bind weed, bitter sweet, and anything else that is in the way. IF you have a way to heat it up that is a good thing. IF/When you have compost with weed seeds you can either add it to a hot pile or steam it using an old gas grill. But to me that is not only more labor intensive but adds to the COG (Cost Of Gardening).
...See More
Questions about Anaerobic Composting
Q
Comments (14)
I'm going to chime in here about the irrational fear that everything is contaminated with pathogens for your garden so you should make sure your compost gets somehow decontaminated by aerobic decay--this is all simply not true. If you put disease-stricken plants in your compost and don't let it break down long enough, you'll have that same disease spread. Here's some good tips to go with that: --everything you're dumping in your compost isn't constantly contaminated with things pathogenic to your garden--for instance, the coffee grounds in my compost don't have septoria. The leaves from my trees don't have fusarium. Why? These plants don't carry those diseases and those diseases don't spontaneously generate. --aerobic decay isn't some cure-all. It is a chemical reaction. Sometimes, if conditions are right, it will get hot enough to sterilize pathogens. It does not achieve that temperature simply because it is aerobic decay--the mulch under my trees is aerobically decaying but not reaching 170 f. --time is the main killer of pathogens. See, if they have no host, they cannot reproduce. When they're not reproducing, they're degrading. The longer anything contaminated is left to sit, the less contaminated it usually becomes. Example: this is why crop rotation is done--if the soil is contaminated with a fungus, grow things not susceptible to it and in a few years, it will have degraded. So, pro-tip for compost: don't throw obviously contaminated materials in it, let it sit & rot for 6 months to a year (or different based on your conditions, mine is 3-4 months) and then use appropriately. I live in a zone where when a plant dies, good chance it was a pathogen so I don't put old plants in the compost. Pathogens in the compost problem solved.
...See More
Lloyd
16 years ago
I can't believe that there is a serious discusion about electricity usage for a blender! It makes me laugh.

Wendy, do what you like to do, don't worry about it. Your garden is gorgeous!

Lloyd
hamiltongardener
16 years ago
I want to move to Wendy's town. The city takes her garden stuff away and brings back finished mulch? Wow.

Mine does too, but it's possible Wendy and I live in the same city. Our garden and kitchen wastes are picked up every week, and we can get the compost free from the city, usually available in the spring.
annpat
16 years ago
So where do you make your concessions?

I wasn't criticizing Wendy, but rather the "Green Tips" pamphlet, which it turns out was written a decade ago.

I don't really care how anyone makes compost as long as they do. I have a chipper, which I use about five days a year on the leaves I use for mulch or in my compost. (The rest of my leaves get bagged and dragged into the woods where I harvest the leaf mold about three years later.) I wouldn't have bought my chipper nowadays. I've had it for 15 years. I don't use a lawnmower ever and I don't use a blender for food scraps. I try to sacrifice the things that aren't so inconvenient, to compensate for my other guilty pleasures.
flora_uk
16 years ago
Lloyd - of course Wendy can do what she likes. However, I am just trying to point out that this blending business would be very time consuming and is not worth the effort. It's about as efficient a use of Wendy's time as cleaning her kitchen floor with cotton buds rather than a mop. As for the electricity consumption, I'm afraid that the attitude that one's own little bit of usage will make no difference is part of the problem. Disappearing energy reserves and global pollution are everyone's responsibility. I'm sorry that makes you laugh, Lloyd.
I am sometimes saddened by those posters on Gardenweb who consider their use of energy largely in terms of monetary cost to themselves and don't see the wider picture. Doing 'what you like' is not going to be an option in the long run.
wendy2shoes
Original Author
16 years ago
My kitchen waste doesn't get picked up...yet. Green bins coming this April, though I doubt I'll be using it for much more than meat scraps, used tissue and the like, because I fully intend to keep composting.
Yard waste (weeds, twigs, leaves) are picked up by the town, and I can go shovel up as much compost as my little honda can carry in the spring and fall. I have three large garbage cans lined up like passengers in the back seat, and four blue bins in the trunk.
Really, really, praying that I don't get rear-ended one day on my way home.
I take my bits of paint, motor oil from oil changes, and any other toxic materials (old propane camping canisters etc.,) on the way up for safe disposal or re-use. You can get some interesting paint colours there for free..they combine like with like..great for outdoor projects.
Our municipal recycling station is doing a great job. (quite close to Hamilton, btw)
Lloyd
16 years ago
No need to apologize Flora, a good chuckle is a good thing.

Now you have me curious...

What problem might you be thinking of that our attitude is contributing to?

Lloyd
paphiocon
16 years ago
"My main plan is to start an open, "U" shaped heap, possibly by using dry-stacked cinder block to contain it, so that I can really get in there and mix it with a fork."

Wendy, I've had a cinder block bin for 11 years now -- I love it! The first run of blocks are laid with the solid side facing, then the other rows are laid so that the holes face. It allows air into the bin and also permits some of the finished compost to drop out, so I can just come along and scoop it up.

Some years I get ambitious and tip the top row over and put potting mix and finished compost into the holes, and then I plant flowers in the "containers". I've been too lazy to take photos, but I will try to get around to it this year.

BTW, I've been drooling over the photo of your garden(s) here and on the Winter Sowing forum.

Cheers,
Constance in NJ
fabric_addict
16 years ago
I've followed this post with interest. I've got very limited yard space and mostly do container gardening. I really have no space for compost piles. I thought creating a food waste slurry maight be a way to fertilize potted plants. Anyone have experience with this?

By the way I have a bit of a rant...
I'm a bit disappointed that wendy2shoes is criticized and shamed for using a blender to assist composting. Yes, it was a good point to remember that electricity was involved in that process and this could be brought up as food for thought rather than criticsm.

I'd suggest considering the following before making somone feel bad for their efforts:
1. Not all people's situations are the same and so not all people will be able to be "green" in the same way. People have different physical and contextual limitations.

2. Every little step counts. Shouldn't we encourage people who are composting (even if it is with electricity) rather than throwing the food scraps away? It seems it would be far more effective to congratulate their current efforts and then gently guide them to greener ways of composting that could work for their situations.

I've had a number of people who have travelled farther along the green road look at me with criticism and disdain for not doing enough. This makes me angry and discourages me from further effort because my current steps forward are not even acknowledged and encouraged.

For those of you farther along the green path, please be patient with and supportive of those of us who are just starting the journey. It takes a long time to learn and to adapt one's lifestyle...there are so many changes to make and it is unrealistic to expect most of us to make great leaps overnight.
idaho_gardener
16 years ago
Blending kitchen scraps sounds like an interesting idea. I think it would especially work with a heavy feeder like a melon. My melon bed is mostly a pile of compost anyway and the addition of the blender compost will just hasten the further decomposition of that compost.

I know I have used coffee grounds straight into the soil of a plant to very good effect, so this blender idea ought to work the same way. Great tip.

And I get my electricity from renewable resources, so that's not much of an issue.
bullthistle
16 years ago
Using a blender to add to the compost is bringing as much discussion about using urine on the perennials. The electricity to use the blender is a weak excuse. I have tons of red wigglers in my compost bin because I aid in the breaking down of pizza crusts, pineapple rinds, and etc. because there was nothing more frustrating then seeing egg shells in my garden beds years after they were deposited or raccoons raiding my compost. If people are so concerned about the environment it certainly isn't showing on the Interstates when cars drive an average of 10 miles over the speed limit. Heck if airlines are slowing down their flight speed to save on fuel, what electricity does a blender use for a 5 minute spurt? I even started saving my urine for the beds and have seen a big change in my water bill, they just raised our bills by 15% because the county lost money last year when they asked us to conserve. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. I am just wondering about all the soap box preachers who condemn anything different, how they save our natural resourses.

Here is a link that might be useful: Propagating Perennials
annpat
16 years ago
I think I'm going to start a new thread because I always wonder why people are so stressed by seeing an eggshell in their garden soil. I hear over and over again how long eggshells take to break down in the garden. Why is everyone so afraid of eggshells? What's your rush? You in a race with someone? Do the eggshells ruin your quest for powder fine soil?

And as far as Wendy being "criticized and shamed", it never happened. There's a difference between discussion and attack.
flora_uk
16 years ago
Ahhhh. There you are annpat. I'd stayed away for a while because the gas guzzlers just weren't getting it. Moral support at last. Thanks.
david52 Zone 6
16 years ago
The wave of the future, for the small-scale apartment compostier, are pigmy Nigerian goats. Take up, I dunno, maybe 1 cupboard, or a big drawer. In the suburban environment, a couple-three out on the back patio, and all your veggie waste needs are met.

Here is a link that might be useful: The ultimate in kitchen appliances
dorisl
16 years ago
Geez, if you're going to rag at somebody for using the blender, I hope you're not using hot water to take a shower, you better be in the backyard dumping the rain barrel on your head and using leaves for toilet paper and washing your clothes on a rock in the mississippiii river.
annpat
16 years ago
Doris please name the person who "ragged at someone for using a blender?" I didn't see that post.

As far as comparing shower taking with blenderizing a banana peel to prepare it for rotting---well, I just can't see the comparison.
gumby_ct
16 years ago
I like to put crushed eggshells around my new seeds & seedlings to deter slugs. So for me, I prefer to see the egg shells so I know where I have planted things. I keep a bucket with just eggshells so I am sure to have them when I want them.

But see Gumby has always been a bit different. Well balanced you might say, ha.
Lloyd
16 years ago
LOL...I'm still trying to discover what exactly "the problem" referred to earlier is?

Lloyd
gumby_ct
16 years ago
ha, good luck wid dat...I thought it was eggshells in garden, but what do I know.
annpat
16 years ago
Lloyd, new friend, you need to read a bit more carefully, too. I know that you're baiting flora, but it was very clear from her post what she considers the problem to be. She said so in the sentence following the one you'd like to debate:

"I'm afraid that the attitude that one's own little bit of usage will make no difference is part of the problem. Disappearing energy reserves and global pollution are everyone's responsibility."

So, go ahead. There it is. Tell us what you'd like to say.
Lloyd
16 years ago
I do believe I already said what I think of the blendering/electricity subject. Makes me laugh.

HRC
david52 Zone 6
16 years ago
I have a neighbor who owns one of the blenders in link. This thing will take a whole tomato and chop it up to the point that the seeds and skin are completely disintegrated. He uses it to 'juice' carrots, ie turn a bunch of carrots into juice.

Anywho, if one were serious about blender composting, or blender gardening, or really into Daiquiris, this is where to look.

Here is a link that might be useful: Bad boy blenders
paulns
16 years ago
Giving eggshells a quick crush in the hand before throwing them in the compost bucket makes them break down much quicker in the pile.

David, if you could talk to my wife about us getting a couple of these...She is being awfully recalcitrant. 'African pygmy goats', I wonder are they the same? They're supposed to be smarter and nicer than dogs.

Here is a link that might be useful: pygmy goats
david52 Zone 6
16 years ago
Thems the same ones, paulns. African pigmy and Nigerian pigmy are different names for the same breed. We used to have a few around the farm when we lived along the West African coast. They're cute, for sure. They're still goats, though. Which means they climb on everything, I'd routinely find them on top of my truck cab, dozing away. And to be honest, a billy goat in rut is just as whiffy as a full sized goat in rut. But shampooed, brushed, and with a ribbon around their neck, they're pretty cute.
Lloyd
16 years ago
"... I hope you're not using hot water to take a shower..."

=

Uses electricity.

Using a blender.

=

Uses electricity.

HRC (apparently, a baiting gas guzzler. BGG, a new acronym, I love it)
trancegemini_wa
16 years ago
I'm always baffled by people who blend up their food scraps before adding to their vermicomposting bins because they get frustrated by how slowly the worms seem to be eating. like you said annepat, what's the rush? it's like some people are so addicted to instant gratification it drives them crazy.

personally I couldnt stand having to wash the blender out every time I had enough scraps. I'd be using it every day. It just sounds like extra work for no real gain and I'm all about keeping things simple.
paulns
16 years ago
"What a goat really likes to do is climb a mountain, browsing on flowers and shrubs along the way." Car = mountain, sounds like. David you must have many stories to tell about your African experiences, I hope you put them on paper. If you include some perspective on organic waste disposal you could post them here.

It took nine years to convince my wife to get chickens; I've been working on the goat file for four...It's a little disappointing they're still goats, she won't want to hear that.

What was the point again? Right: feed your scraps through a goat, not a blender.
billinpa
16 years ago
I just wanted to point something out that hasnt been yet. As a gas guzzling person myself. I drive 160 miles a day round trip for work.

But some of you are so "green" but yet your sitting here typing on a computer???? Does that not use unnecessary electricity???

If using a blender to process her kitchen waste works for her then good for her. At least she is using it.

To the ones that think she is wasting electricity for doing so and damaging the earth because if it then maybe you should turn off you TV and your computer your wasting valuable resources.

Man some extremists amaze me!!!

It really neededs to be said that some people in this thread are major hypocrits.

I do agree withsome of you that said its not worth it. Freezing may be a better option until you have enough to make the trip to the heap.
david52 Zone 6
16 years ago
Goats will also pull goat carts. Actually, paulns, African composting, per se, exists in towns and cities, with individuals any organic scraps are used to feed chickens, and anything that can possibly be recycled / reused as something else is - any container is reused, tin cans are flattened and used as roofing shingles, paper feeds the termites, and everything just sort of disappears. In 25 years, we never had any trash collection, just a compost pile out back, and somebody would always take the jars cans, or anything that wasn't organic. The last place we stayed, on the shores of Lake Victoria, we had a group of 5 foot long monitor lizards who would check out the compost pile and eat anything they thought they could.

With larger towns, compost happens and goats are an integral part of the operation. Everybody piles their garbage in an empty lot, mountains of the stuff, usually with a herd of goats hanging around. It turns to compost, obviously. One place I stayed, the compostibles would add up, and stack up, all dry season long, a pile maybe 10 feet high over a square block. And then when the rains came, this provided sufficient moisture to get the mountain going. It radiated an amazing amount of heat.

This all worked well until the advent of the cheap plastic bag, which the goats would eat and couldn't digest.

In some cities, folks give directions by the garbage mounds. "Take the North road, and go by 4 garbage heaps. My place is 3rd on the left"
Lloyd
16 years ago
Whoa....Hold on thar Billinpa...no sense in getting all logical when there are conclusions to be jumped to. It is much more funner to obfuscate and assume things than ascertain some other possibilities....

(Picture Lloyd scratching his head in deep thought) Hmmmm...I wonder if Wendy has solar panels to generate her electricity, or maybe a wind turbine, that would be WAY cool (I'd love to have a wind turbine). That would be quite "green" I'm thinking. Pity I didn't ask her....

Wait a minute...did Wendy say a cup of water in her blender? For shame Wendy. You should be saving your urine for that. The nerve, using good clean water. But wait, I may have jumped to another conclusion, she just might be using the water from boiling the veggies or taters. Sorry bout that Wendy, I guess I shoulda asked first.

Lloyd HRC

P.S. Kinda sarcastic ain't I.
wendy2shoes
Original Author
15 years ago
Just wondered if I could put a word in here. I didn't realize that I would cause such a kafuffle, or to translate for flora, an "argy bargy" over an innocent question. I do my best, I refuse (extra packaging) reduce, reuse, and recycle.

I do ask my husband to pee around the beds, (he has no problem with that) to keep the rabbits away. I would like to have three hens in the yard (wasn't that a song?..no sorry it was three cats..) but the town bylaws won't let me.

I live in Canada, which has inherent difficulties. My furnace was still running yesterday, as it only got to 7c, and we can't afford to install geo thermic.

I have a bucket in the kitchen, into which I pour off excess water being used for rinsing vegetables, getting cold to hot, etc, and pour it off onto the garden.

I would love to have a gray water cistern in my house, to take care of that wastage with just a flip of a lever, but, we can't afford the expense to install one.

Some people have very limited incomes. My dream is to get off the grid altogether, but if you live in a city, on a fixed income, that ideal may be difficult to acheive.

We all do our own, in our little ways to try to do better. I apologize to those who took offense to me using electricity unnecessarily.

I will not cast the first stone.
treeinnj
15 years ago
billinpa & pt03 - sure am glad to see some folks here who are like-minded w/me - I think everyone has different reasons, purposes &/or agendas w/compost, & each is entitled to his own. Heck, some of us might even compost, love replenishing the earth & conservationism & still not believe in "global warming" ;)

BTW, Wendy, if you like to blend, blend away. Keep the enjoyment in the process!

All the Best, Tree (who has a hard enough time getting the counter-top crock out out to the pile - down 1 flight & out back door - never mind adding another step - which is why the phrase "to each his own" was coined - and should really be applied here more frequently)
annpat
15 years ago
Wendy, I don't think that you or I or flora see things very differently.

I repeat that a careful reader would have noticed that I was merely responding to the irony of a booklet called "Green Tips" recommending blenderizing a product in preparation for rotting. If the booklet had been named something different, say, "Not Green Tips" I might have let it go. But I'm a careful reader, and I don't like people getting horns waggled, so I pointed out the obvious.

But, I am sorry I responded. I'll try not to do that again. Because, yeah, I see the point---How could a person who takes showers comment on anything??? I mean, really!!!
madmagic
15 years ago
"It really neededs to be said that some people in this thread are major hypocrits."

No. It does not need to be said. And statements of personal attack are not welcome, here. Please stop writing them.

No-one on this thread has personally attacked Wendy. (And if you think otherwise, please quote the words. I've followed this thread as it was posted, and I've re-read every word carefully just now.)

People have expressed their individual opinions about using a blender to process materials for compost. Those opinions were IMO generally expressed in friendly, positive, polite and considerate ways. And if you think otherwise, please quote the words.

As I understand it, the rules of GardenWeb -- and the general style of most posts in this forum, most of the time -- allow for free expression of personal opinions. Speak your mind, please.

But please -- speak your mind on the issues. Talking about personalities lowers the tone of the conversation here and can quickly turn decent online conversations into fights.

Everyone, please... stop the sniping. Let's get back to soil, compost and mulch, okay?

All the best,
-Patrick

p.s. Wendy, this kind of lowering of discussion doesn't take place here often and I'm sorry it happened on a thread where you made your first post. I'm familiar with most of the posters who disagreed with you, and IMO not one of them meant any of their comments to be understood in any way as a personal attack on you. They disagreed with you; they didn't mean to diss you.
david52 Zone 6
15 years ago
Last summer, I bought an big electric drill and a 3' long bulb auger, a 100 ft extension cord, and a 50 gallon plastic bucket to make a slurry out of newspaper so it would compost better. It worked pretty good until I was distracted and put the auger through the side of the bucket, and poured 50 gallons of stinking, rotting newspaper slurry on my shoes.

I wonder if they make a big enough blender.......I mean, I already have the cord..... :-)
paulns
15 years ago
A cart-pulling goat is a very nice image to offer my wife, thanks.
You've reminded me of two things, a documentary on the garbage mountains of Lagos (I think it was) - veritable landscapes of inhabited islands of mostly plastic garbage; and of a trip to Cuba a few years ago, where the only garbage we saw in rural areas was a very small pile of pop bottles in any given yard. They have a lot of pigs there, another omnivorous animal.

The plastic bag is certainly a curse.

Monitor lizards on the shores of Lake Victoria.
cynthia_h
15 years ago
Having lived in Berkeley, California, for 17 years (and now, blessedly, NOT in Berkeley), I was surrounded by "more ecologically correct than thou" sorts for years and years. But I also started composting while living in Berkeley, thanks to the very subsidized Biostack bin we purchased while living there.

I originally threw eggshells into the bin in two or maybe three parts (if I had messed up while cracking them). After "timing" one particular eggshell at 5 years+ to disintegrate, I decided to smash them in my hands. OK; they now took a mere 3 years.

So now I wait until I have a large yogurt container of eggshells which have dried up (the egg white inside), and then--GASP!--I put them into my old blender (capacity 2 quarts) and pulse/burst them until they're pulverized. Maybe a total of 1 minute every two weeks or so of electricity. And I walk them out to the compost bin, and they just disappear by the time I turn the pile next, whether that be two weeks or two months.

(Too bad this forum doesn't show when people joined, their general location, or how many posts they've made; it's easier to keep track of folks' names when this info is provided.)
bldaboll
15 years ago
Hi, I'm very interested in this issue of shredding or at least reducing in size the scraps we put into our worm bin or compost tumbler. I keep looking for something manual that would shred (a bit) things like watermelon rind, banana peel, coffee filters... you know the usual stuff. I want this for my home use BUT I also do worm composting at my elementary school with the food waste from lunch. We bought a big apple grinder but haven't tried it out yet. I wish someone would create something manual that would shred paper and food waste or tell me of a tool that would do it. Thanks in advance.
luckygal
15 years ago
The "something manual" that I use for all melon rinds is a sharp knife. I find it kind of fun (I know, I need a life!) to slice the rinds into half inch strips about 4" long. If I'm lazy I just chuck 'em out in large pieces. They still decompose.

On the subject of other ways to compost, we've often just buried our daily supply of goodies between the plants. Cover it with the shovelful of dirt removed from the hole and the worms take care of it. I'm sure someone will say how "bad" in some way this is, but it's worked for us over many summers with absolutely no problems. No wild animals nor our dogs ever dug anything up. Perhaps because we always have one coffee filter with UCG's which covers up the scent.

We've never had a fruit fly in the kitchen compost bin but empty it every day in the evening. Even in our cold zone 3 we add to the compost bin all winter. Just trudge out through the snow and dump it on top of the snow. Melts and rots every spring/summer.

Composting is the easiest thing to do which is good for the earth. Why make it difficult?
cathyd_gardener
15 years ago
Right on, tiffy_Z5_6_can (and paulns, pt03, fabric_addict, etc). I LOVE to use the food processor on my veggie and fruit scraps. I am also using a paper shreader! Many good points made here.

To keep out fruit flies, I use a coffee can with a lid. Never have a problem.

Cathy

Here is a link that might be useful: my garden
pennymca
15 years ago
David,

I tried to post a link to another site that has a great group on papercrete but GW wouldn't allow it. Lots of ideas for bigger "blenders" for newspaper slurry, from using an old wringer type washing machine to one that uses a power washer with a certain type of nozzle to pulverize the paper.

Do YOU "Y...o?"check it out. Papercreters.
Demeter
15 years ago
Manual ways of reducing melon rinds and such involve a heavy knife, or, if you want to take out your aggression on the fruit, a machete. My mother had a manual meat grinder when I was a kid, and I've seen vegetable slicers of the same sort. If one of those can reduce carrots to slivers, it would do the same for melon rinds. Paper can be hand-shredded or you can use a paper cutter to cut it into strips and then cut the strips crosswise.

Either way, it's a lot of work, and I don't know if most people are willing to put that much effort into it. Generally, if something requires a little personal effort and a little electricity, it's more likely to get done than if it requires a lot of manual effort and time and no electricity. If that were not the case, "labor-saving" electrical devices would never have become popular.

To be completely honest, I do have a powerful blender with a container dedicated to compost. I tend to use it when I'm cleaning out the fridge and getting rid of all the leftovers that are growing green fuzzy things. I'll usually wind up with a bucket full of nasty slurry, which then gets dumped into the compost pile and covered with shredded leaves or wood chips. My blender can handle meat and bones as well as veggies, enabling me to compost things that are usually on the "do not compost" list by breaking them down into tiny particles which rot quickly before attracting flies.

Most of the time, however, I just dump things into the compost without shredding.

I think that the energy used in shredding is offset by the energy used in manufacturing a black plastic bag, using a big smoke-belching diesel truck to take the bag to the landfill (or the incinerator), and then using a big smoke-belching diesel bulldozer to bury the bag in the landfill (or using more fuel to burn it); either way the organic material will be lost to the ecosystem., and in the case of the incinerator, which is where my trash would go, the carbon is emitted as CO2. IMO, it's much better to have it in the garden nurturing the roses, no matter how it got there.
witeowl
15 years ago
"...it's much better to have it in the garden nurturing the roses, no matter how it got there."

Quoted for truth. :)
aezarien
15 years ago
I have way too much during the growing season so it all gets chunked in the bin. During the winter however, when I am basically looking at scraps I will blend, pull back the mulch, and pour directly on the dirt. I haven't had any smell or bug issues and the plants and worms seem to love it.
mirjam_c21alliance_com
15 years ago
I have been reading all the posts but still have a question: we own 0.5 acre, live with a well and a septic system -yeah, pretty basic... I do have a vegetable garden but never had much luck with a compost heap. My hubby gave me a Vitamix blender and I have been blending my veggie scraps and used coffee grinds with water in the blender and poured them into my garden beds. I noticed that it enhanced the structure of the soil, has anyone any idea whether it would hurt the seeds?
By the way, it's just my hubby and me, we eat very basic (no fast food etc) and do not have buckets of scraps every week.
Thanks for your feedback.
fayea
15 years ago
I used to have a device back in the 1970's that was essentially a 3 gallon metal can with a hole in the lid that was fitted with a long shaft and blade at the bottom. You would hook your power drill to the shaft and with a little water in your kitchen garbage, it soon became a soupy blended mixture. You could do fairly large stinky batches without destroying your kitchen blender. We just poured the slop into little trenches directly in the garden. It was wonderful. I have been looking for such a device recently to no avail. Has anyone else come across such a thing?
wendy2shoes
Original Author
15 years ago
Could I posssibly ask that if anyone wants to add to this thread that they start another one? I mistakenly directed replies to my inbox when I first posted, and frankly, don't want to hear about it anymore.
Livin' the 'vida loca' over at wintersown now, never to venture forth again. (Except maybe to "lurk" at Garden Junk for a laugh now and then.)
Betty Headland
2 years ago
Well I’ve been doing this a long time but throwing it down the sink kinda like a garbage disposal. It cuts down on amount of trash we take to the curb. Even egg cartons disappear with water. Starting tomorrow it’s going in my garden. I feed meat products to the crows. They love it.
annpat
9 months ago
I'm tempted to go back and edit stuff, make predictions.

annpat: 15 years ago: "I'm worried that using electricity to ready compost for rotting is going to cause a world-wide pandemic some day."

Question about 'blender' composting

Comments (70)

Related Discussions

wendy2shoesOriginal Author

wendy2shoesOriginal Author

wendy2shoesOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

wendy2shoes
Original Author

wendy2shoes
Original Author

wendy2shoes
Original Author