I'd go with Chiltern Seeds, but they are ex-pen-siiive, and you don't get a whole lot of seeds in most cases. But that's if you want really rare, unique stuff.

For "everyday" annuals and perennials, I like Stokes Seed. Their prices are extremely reasonable and you get a LOT of seed for your money. Even if half of the seed was dust, you would still have good value for your money.

I ran across this the other day, but I dont think it has a printable catalog, nor have I ordered from it ( yet).
www.cheapseeds.com

As for as I can tell, they are cheap and get a LOT of seeds for the price. IF I remember correctly on one thing I think it was 500 seeds for $1.50-$2. Hope I helped a little

I would have to say Stokes Seeds, they are incredibly reasonable, if you order a larger packet size. However, I have never ever had problems with Park Seed at all whatsoever. I am sorry you are having problems with them! Is anyone else?

I called them the other day to see if they were going to have another BOGO sale like they had last year. I didnt really expect them (or any company for that matter!) to tell me, but took a chance anyway. They are apparently not going to have the same sale as they did last year. Huge bummer for me, as I saved like $500 last year in seed expense.

Debbie, I get almost perfect germination from Park Seed. What seed did you order? Was it available in pellets? I dont know that knowing for sure the packing year will make too big a difference, I have seed from many years ago, and they still germinate just fine. This is so controversial, some people have problems, some dont have any at all with aged seed. Many people believe this is kinda a gimmick to get people to buy fresh seed every year, and some people swear by using fresh seed.

Everyone grows their seeds differently, have differences in their technique. Are you eliminating that as a problem? That maybe you should try something different? I'm not trying to cut you down at all, my passion is to help other people learn to grow from seed. Though, you may not be new at it at all. I just havent seen people complain about Park Seed before. It will be interesting to see if others have problems.

Many seeds are very tiny and dustlike, there isnt much that can be done about it. Begonia seed is the most dustlike I have ever seen, and it germinated for me by the thousands! Petunia seed is also very tiny, but germinates so easily.

Maybe you could briefly explain your germination technique and see if people here can offer successful tips, maybe something you havent tried before. I would like to help, if you want.

You may want to check out this thread...

Here is a link that might be useful: Seed Source Discussion - May

Actually, I like Parks' foil package. Pretty much ensures that no moisture penetrates. And I actually think they have one of the best germination rates. I can pretty much count on old packages of Park seed germinating years later and I think the packaging has something to do with it. It would be no fun to shop at just one seed supplier :-) I like Parks, Jelitto's, JL Hudson, Pinetree, Antique Flowers Select Seeds, Patrick Seeds, and Swallowtail seeds. They have different advantages - price/selection. All are good.

There are several companies that I like. For the basics, I love Crosman's Seeds. Their packages with generous amounts are only $.59 to $.69 each, and this includes things like Primrose Polyanthus and Delphiniums. They also have a good assortment of vegetables.

I like www.hardyplants.com too. Their variety is incredible. The campanula list just goes on and on. Their prices generally run from $2.00 and a little more; however, they offer some seeds like primula japonica for about $.90. The number of seeds varies according to the particular plant- fewer with rare ones.

JL Hudson is a good one too. His seeds run about $2.00 to $2.50. He carries a lot of rare seeds and offers a wide selection.

Comstock Ferre is also a reasonable, good seed company with a nice variety of seeds offered.

I'm new to seed-starting this year and I suspect that most of my failed efforts have been due to not giving the seeds what they need to germinate. I finally understand that the "one size fits all" method of seed-starting just doesn't work. I don't think I could choose just one seed supplier because I get such a kick out of looking at the different selections they all have. I think Harris Seeds and Swallowtail both have great selections but they are quite expensive. There's always the Burpee catalogue to fire up one's imagination. Park's seeds are great though. Personnally I prefer the websites that have pictures with all the seeds, that way I can really dream!

luciecat, even if you don't order a THING from Stokes Seed, DO request (or even buy) a copy of their catalog. They give very detailed instructions on how to germinate everything they sell right there in the catalog. Just bear in mind that a two dollar packet (or three dollar) of, say, beans, will keep you in bean seed for a VERY long time. Some of their seeds are more expensive, but the quantities are correspondingly generous.

I could never limit myself to ordering seeds from only one company. Each year I tie myself in knots researching the varieties I'd like to grow, who stocks them, how much they cost, all of which goes on an Excel spreadsheet. (If I put as much effort into my paid office job, I'd be running the company by now!)
I then end up with far too many seeds, all of which have to be logged on another spreadsheet with germination details. And then the forgotten 20 packs of free seed from the Royal Horticultural Society (chosen from a long list back last November) land on my doormat... The whole process is ridiculously stressful. I then spend the next few months frantically trying to get all my seeds started, then pricking out, potting on, etc. Plenty of things get forgotten about or left in tiny pots for far too long, which brings on more stress and guilt... and this is supposed to be fun?
However, to answer the question: I tried JL Hudson for the first time this year and will definitely order from them again. Also, Plant World in Devon have a really interesting seed list, as does Derry Watkins' Special Plants nursery (she's an American living in the UK). BUT if I was limited to just one company, it would probably be Chiltern Seeds because their catalogue is so extensive.

I like Select Seeds . But I'm with Ornata, there's no way I could limit myself to just one ;) I've also had great luck with Swallowtail Garden Seeds.

Just stay away from the 'pumpkin nook' and 'Autumn Ridge Nursery'. Nothing I ordered from the pumpkin nook germinated, and Autumn Ridge has sent me so many mislabeled plants and roots that I can't count!!

I have ordered from cheapseeds.com They have large amounts of seeds at a good price. I received my seeds in 3 days in perfect shape. No pictures on the packages but all I need is lots of seeds.

Here is a link that might be useful: flower seeds