Organic Seed vs Non-organic
pushindirt
16 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (31)
Kimmsr
16 years agorobin_maine
16 years agoRelated Discussions
Organic yield vs Non-Organic yield - or - U of M vs MSU
Comments (10)I have to agree with fruitgirl, but for reasons that most people seldom think about. No doubt about it, organic yields are comparable to conventional on a bushel-to-bushel basis. And I agree that organic methods do work. On certain plots, with certain techniques they may even out produce conventional several times over. However, what we seem to forget is that organic practices include longer rotation schedules than conventional. I live on a conventional farm in the upper Midwest and here the rotation is probably the same for most Midwest farm: corn, then soybeans, then corn again, then soybeans again, and so on, forever. An organic farmer would also plant corn, then soybeans. The third year is where the difference begins to show. The farmer is going to plant oats, buckwheat, or rye early in the spring, and then more than likely, it will get plowed under to break the weed cycle. After it gets plowed, the field will be seeded to alfalfa, or maybe timothy hay. If it is alfalfa, the field will remain in alfalfa for several years until the cycle begins again. THIS IS GREAT FOR THE SOIL!! But look what it does for the on-going, overall yield of corn and soybeans: over four years the organic farm has only produced one-fourth of the conventional yield of corn and soybeans. Of course, we can argue that is how farming should be done, however, our society and culture must undergo a tremendous culture shift in order for that to succeed. A whole lot less meat, and much more vegetables and grain. So fruitgirl rightly stated: "I'm not arguing that organic farms do not experience good yields. I'm saying that a large-scale organic farm doesn't get the same yield as a large-scale conventional farm because they have a harder time battling the effects of monoculture. And, as I stated above, the US (and most other developed countries) are not structured in such a way to allow for a multitude of small farms". In the end, it is this "really-good-for-soil" cycle that reduces overall yields, not the lack of chemicals applied to the soil. Small organic farms do out produce conventional farms. Small organic vegetable and fruit operations are better for our health, the environment, and our society as a whole. And despite the fact that I would wish the whole planet to go organic, I agree with fruitgirl, that our structure of food production is now geared towards feeding 6 billion people and difficult to change. Yes, we do add more organic acres every year, but China is adding them even faster than the US. The US hasnt met its need for organic production since 2000. Nearly 15% of all organic food sold in this country is now imported, and at the rate of production of organic food look-alike junk (Oreos, Cheetos, toaster pastries, etc.) the imports are only going to rise. Moreover, the rate of conversion of conventional to organic has slowed down. Unfortunately, I suspect suburbanites often fail to fully understand farming and fall victim to the shouts of the anti-agribiz types....See MoreAre there any studies into organic vs non-organic methods
Comments (1)I can't think of any studies right off. Organic is becoming more popular, but synthetics have worked for years, as well....See MoreOrganic Seed vs Non Organic Seed
Comments (0)If I am planting a veggie garden and polan for it to be organic, should I use organic seed? Wheat is the difference? I thought"organic" was once it is in the ground, growing it organic. Help my understand. Thanks Jeff...See MoreOrganic vs. non-organic growing
Comments (12)A lot of people might use organic methods but live right on top of large farms that use lots of chemicals so these chemicals are within an 1/8 mile or less. I believe as this is just my opinion that this negates any claims that their stuff is chemical free. Runoff is water from rain and melted snow which is not absorbed and captured by the soil, but runs over the ground and in and out of loose soil. Farm runoff is water leaving farm fields because of rain - melted snow - or possibly irrigation methods. As runoff moves, it picks up and carries pollution, which it can deposit into rivers,small ponds, lakes, coastal waters, and underground sources of drinking water. Agricultural runoff include,s pollution from soil erosion, livestock feeding systems, grazing, plowing, animal waste, and herbicides-pesticides, irrigation water, and fertilizer. Pollutants from farming include soil particles, pesticides, herbicides, heavy metals, salts, and nutrients such as excessive nitrogen - phosphorus. Large levels of nitrates from fertilizers in the runoff can infiltrate drinking water I wonder if these so-called organic method gardeners that say they are chemical-free explain this to their customers. All certified organic growers are the proper distance away from farm fields that use lots of different chemicals to prevent cross contamination or at least they should be. When I choose to grow produce for sale I do not mention anything even close to the word organic because I am NOT certified and tested and inspected and licensed ORGANIC If people ask me what chemicals I use for my operation they get all of my information. If they don,t ask I do not say anything because the weed/bug sprays that I use are available over the counter and are legal to use without special fed, or county-govt. permits. Nick...See Morepushindirt
16 years agobuffburd
16 years agopushindirt
16 years agotrancegemini_wa
16 years agopushindirt
16 years agotrancegemini_wa
16 years agoKimmsr
16 years agopushindirt
16 years agocrankyoldman
16 years agopushindirt
16 years agokasmiller25_hotmail_com
16 years agopushindirt
16 years agodavid52 Zone 6
16 years agoKimmsr
16 years agopaulns
16 years agothesummertime_gmail_com
15 years agoemyers
15 years agocrankyoldman
15 years agorangerbubba
15 years agoskagit_goat_man_
15 years agonate6172
15 years agoorganicguy
15 years agoekgrows
15 years agojacobjguntorius_hotmail_com
14 years agojustaguy2
14 years agofarmersteve
14 years agoDan _Staley (5b Sunset 2B AHS 7)
14 years agofreq_band
9 years ago
Related Stories
ORGANIZINGSmall Steps to Organizing Success
Take care of bite-size projects, and your home's big picture will be an organized dream before you know it
Full StoryINSPIRING GARDENSFrom Concrete Lot to Gracious Organic Garden in Seattle
Plants, pests and even weeds have a place in this landscape, which offers an edible bounty and a feast for the eyes
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESHow to Switch to an Organic Landscape Plan
Ditch the chemicals for a naturally beautiful lawn and garden, using living fertilizers and other nontoxic treatments
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESOrganic Matters: Thwart Insect Pests With Trap Crops
Add a few sacrificial plants to your garden to lure insects away from the harvest
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGN12 Great Ideas for Organization In the Kitchen
Spring cleaning? Here's how to whip your kitchen into shape
Full StoryORGANIZINGGet Organized: Are You a Piler or a Filer?
Tote out the bins and baskets and learn how to be an organized piler if file cabinets leave you cringing
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNGet It Done: Organize Your Kitchen Drawers
Clear 'em out and give the contents a neat-as-a-pin new home with these organizing and storage tips
Full StoryORGANIZINGYour Total Home Organizing and Decluttering Guide
Take it slow or be a speed demon — this room-by-room approach to organizing and storage will get your home in shape no matter how you roll
Full StoryORGANIZING4 Questions to Help You Organize Your Favorite Photos
Organize your keeper photos with a system that's just right for you, whether it's in the cloud or you can hold it in your hand
Full Story
Kimmsr