Tomato problem identification (w/ pics): Has anyone had Rust b4?

15 years ago

I am trying to identify what is wrong with my tomato plant. I have checked problem solver #2 as well as searched the internet. The only thing I can find that looks close to what is happening to my plant is the rust fungus. The research I've been able to find says that rust can be a problem along the pacific (where I live), but I can only find information on the rust fungus effecting beans. Has anyone out there had rust on a tomato plant?

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

What does this look like: TOMATO SPOT PROBLEM (5 Pics)

I'm sorry to post about this again, but i found a few similar spots on one of my other tomatoes. If this is rust, then I think there is some stuff I could do now to save the plants. My other theory is that it could be Alternaria Canker because of the black powder appearing on the stems (sort of visible in one of the pics).

I will take a section into the LA extension office if I can't get it under control- but the guy at OSH just told me the wait for results could be over a month, so I'm hoping to "trial and error it" with the new spots I've found on my other tomatoes.

Here is some info I posted earlier about this plant:

-About 1.5 weeks ago I noticed the new growth was purple tinted with dark purple veins. I thought it was potassium so I used seaweed.

-a few days later I noticed what appeared to be black powder on the undersides of some of the older leaves- when I touched the stuff it was sticky. The man at the nursery said it was probably sooty black mold from the neighboring magnolia tree and it should wash off, but it didn't wash off. I tried Safer fungicide.

-today I found that the 'sooty black mold' (?) has spread all over the plant. Not only can I not wash it off, I CAN'T SCRAPE THE STUFF OFF!! The powdery looking black spots have burned into the leaves and it is on the tops of some as well as the stem.

There is no yellowing on the leaves and the black spots are TINY- seriously- the size of sand. The plant is producing tomatoes and has many flowers, though I noticed a very faint "lighter" blotch on the largest tomato (still green). Also, I would have to say the growth of the entire plant has slowed in the last few weeks.

Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance.

Comments (6)

digdirt2
15 years ago
Has anyone out there had rust on a tomato plant? I never have nor have I ever heard of it being a problem but since these plants are apparently indoors and house with other carriers I suppose it is possible.

But I would think using the fungicide should have at least improved the condition IF it is a fungus. I don't know off hand the concentration of the chemical in the Safer product - I know that the stronger concentrations of at lest 25-29% are the ones usually recommended.

But I do have a suggestion to try. It is possible that this is bacterial rather than fungul - just a guess from the pics but perhaps bacterial spot. If it is then a fungicide won't help but a peroxide spray might. It can't hurt and might help. Mix up a 9:1 dilution of water and hydogen peroxide (9 parts water to 1 part HP) and mist it on the infected areas. They won't disappear - the damage is done to the leaf tissue - but they shouldn't spread either IF it is bacterial.

When can these plants go outside where the sun and wind/air circulation may control some of this problem?

Dave
jean001
15 years ago
Don't know what it is. But it's not rust.
Related Discussions
problems w/ corn and cucumbers,other
Q
Comments (12)
bless578 Two years ago I raised 12 cucumbers in 12oz cups. They had grown great under the lights for three weeks. They were set out for three days for a few hours before planting. I planted them in the evening on a mid seventy degree day. The next day the temp hit high eighties with sun all day. I noticed that evening the leaves were losing their green color turning white. The sun burnt them all, almost all the leaves turned white, but four plants lived. I didn't make the same mistake the following year. This years I raised about 36, two in a cup, 18 cups. This year when the plants were about an inch tall, they were set out (it was cool at the time) each day where they got morning sun until about noon and left in the shade until evening when they were brought inside (our cold frame was full). The following week the plants were set out where they got sun all day and left out since the night temp stayed above 50* that week. These are the plants below. All doing well. Last years vine patch in the same location. Our 9 rows of Honey and Pearl corn in the background. It seems that some gardeners over water and over fertilize. Lightly moist potting soil is good, wet not good. We might give seedling (tomatoes, peppers) a 1/2 strength miracle grow watering a week or so before repoting to 2 quart pots. A week after we repot we give them another 1/2 strength drink of one cup each. The day before we plant to the garden (several weeks later) we give them one cup of full strength miracle grow mix and more water if needed. The cucumbers and watermelons in the pics did not receive any miracle grow. They were only in the 12oz cups for three weeks and were about three or four inches tall when planted (I looked through my pics folder but it seems I did not take any pics). Before planting I till the area. I then dig about a 12" wide buy 8" deep hole. We mix together about 1/3 well composted horse manure 2/3rds soil and a good sprinkling of 10-10-10 fertilizer, place the plants and water. A week later we dress all around the plants in a 12" circle with more 10-10-10 and cover the fertilizer with a little loose soil. Corn wants sun right from the git go. Last year in the pic above with the corn, I started the first three lower rows in three boxes with soil from the garden. I scratched in the soil (2" deep) a 1 1/4" grid and pressed a seed in each square with a unsharpened pencil about 1/2+" deep . Since I had soaked the seeds in warm wet potting soil (about 26 hours in a plastic container in a warm place ~80+*~ with a lid, one cup potting soil soggy wet, 340 seeds). I could actually see the tiny sprouts coming out of some of the seeds after the 26 hours. I planted the seeds and had plants nearly a 1/2" high under my grow lights in a week, all but about eight sprouted. A week later they were nearly 2" high and I planted them out. I took a table spoon and scooped out each plant and planted them, three 50' rows. Even at only 2" high the roots had started tangling with one another. I thought it would take me about an hour and a half to plant them, it took me over three hours. I even had to tarp cover them one night because of frost(not fun). Even though I had sweet corn three weeks before anyone else in the area I would never do it again. It was an experiment and it worked out well. Almost all the plants lived but I had deer that decided they wanted a sample so I had to replant some areas in the rows. I'm an experimenter and just a novice weekend gardener with little experience but I hope that info helps. I have no idea what I'm doing. Here is a link that might be useful: Mom's Garden Pics and Info
...See More
Please post pics of your citrus leaf problems-help w/ ID of cause
Q
Comments (59)
Could be a fungus like Vladimir said, could also be an insect egg or just dirt on a bit of fluff. However, I'm more concerned with how dusty the leaves are. I may just be dust or it could be the beginnings of a spider mite infestation. It's a good idea to wash off the leaves from time to time, like maybe every 4-6 weeks. Take them outside and hose them off, or if that's not possible, put them in the shower and shower them off with cool water. Then let them drain well and put them back where they were. It helps prevent spider mites as they're attracted to dusty plants. And your plants love the rinsing off!
...See More
If you had to teach a Newbee one thing about growing tomatoes
Q
Comments (92)
Make sure your plants have stakes or cages that will handle the vines when they are 2 or 3 times the current height. I'll let someone else address the Brandywine issue. The link at the end of this post gives url's of several good tomato databases, as well as two books about tomato varieties which you might want to look for at your local public library or bookstore. Re. Patio Hybrid, some quotations from various databases and vendors: ===== Patio F1 Hybrid Determinate The very compact plants, about two feet tall, are a very reliable producer of lots of tomatoes the size of tennis-balls (or larger), and have attractive dark green foliage. Although the plants are determinate, they produce so many tomatoes that the sheer weight of the fruit may pull the plants over, so it's best to give them some support - a stake or two will suffice. Tomatoes are ripe in about 70 days after transplanting out. ===== Hybrid. Early small salad tomato with red, 4-ounce, tennis-ball-sized (or larger) fruit. Dwarf, 2-foot plants developed for bedding and containers with dark green, bushy, potato-leaf foliage. Days To Maturity: 50-70 ===== Photos of Patio Hybrid, and more comments: http://davesgarden.com/guides/pf/go/30768/ Here is a link that might be useful: http://forums.gardenweb.com/forums/load/tomato/msg0622294625839.html?3
...See More
Advice please on w.c's -style and function- long w/pics
Q
Comments (9)
Yes, I know the post was really detailed. I waffled about whether to put that much detail in it, but felt like I'd covered the basic ideas/options myself but kept running into obstacles that I tried to outline in the post so folks maybe would understand the problems with most of the options I thought of. It was not my intent to make anyone's head explode. Thanks to all of you for your ideas, however. I do appreciate it. Igloochic, I hadn't really thought of hanging glass...that's an interesting option. I do like the Asian look of shoji which might work, maybe in a shutter? Marti8a, I love that pic...they were my first choice, but don't know if I can get a 9' span. Think I will have to visit a decor store that sells shades and see what they say. Thanks, again
...See More
garyt33
15 years ago
Darcy, It looks like leaf spot which is a fungus disease. The fungus that causes the disease lives in the soil. Have you grown tomatoes in the same spot before? Check out the link.

Here is a link that might be useful: Septoria Leaf Spot of Tomato
purplemage
15 years ago
I agree with the PP...septoria fungus. I have the same thing on one of my very new seedlings. Supposedly it doesn't develop until time of fruit set...and I'm about 4 weeks early for that...but it best fits what I'm seeing on my tomato leaves.
darcygarden
Original Author
15 years ago
Thanks so much for the info. Sorry it took me a few days to reply, my work schedule has been a little insane...

I had thought leaf spot was possible, but the beginning stage of this fungus was like nothing I could find (picture or description) describing Septoria. It looked like a black/brown dust (raised) was covering the undersides of the leaves- like someone held the plant upside-down and spilled soil on it :) If two of you think that's what it is, then it must be. I thought rust both because that was the ONLY fungus that looked even remotely similar and we had rust on a jasmine vine planted about 6 feet away in the flower bed (this tomato is potted so it does not share soil with any plants).

The good news is- after an all out assault of (Safer) fungicide (every 4 days) and seaweed- the plant appears to be in recovery. A couple of the young tomatoes appear to be a bit deformed so I'm going to keep a close eye on it. The leaf loss was quite extensive, so I may have a problem with sun scald. (btw, in a couple of the photos you can see the whole plant behind me- it's the potted plant on the white stand).

QUESTIONs: If I start using Fish Emulsion with the seaweed now will it encourage some more leaf production to help the sun scald problem? Or will any new leaf growth be effected by the fungus?

The plant is potted so I have not grown anything in the soil before, it must have picked up the disease at the nursery. This is my ONLY potted tomato and I'm noticing a few spots on my other tomatoes (planted in a garden), if I catch this fungus early enough will it contaminate the soil?

Sorry if it was unclear, all of my plants are outside (I brought my laptop out and used the camera built into it to take the pics- GO MAC!!!)

Thanks again for all the posts, diagnosing this little fungus had truly been driving me crazy!
purplemage
15 years ago
..."- like someone held the plant upside-down and spilled soil on it "...

Funny you should say that. That is the *exact* thing I thought when I first saw my plants looking like that. Then I realized it didn't brush or wash off.

Glad you found a treatment that seems to be working for you.

My guess is that there's a distinct possibility that even when caught early, the soil will harbor the fungus easily and it will reproduce and spread. Probably only takes a few spores and a bit of moisture.

Tomato problem identification (w/ pics): Has anyone had Rust b4?

Comments (6)

digdirt2

jean001

Related Discussions

garyt33

purplemage

darcygarden
Original Author

purplemage

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Tomato problem identification (w/ pics): Has anyone had Rust b4?

Comments (6)

digdirt2

jean001

Related Discussions

garyt33

purplemage

darcygardenOriginal Author

purplemage

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

darcygarden
Original Author