It's not evergreen: I have a deciduous azalea (yellow flowers) and a non-strident orange asiatic growing through the branches. As the azalea leafs up the fading lily is well-disguised. A similar arrangement has developed between a Hamamelis and an asiatic, with a bit of help from a 'Sulphur Queen' Rhododendron. Other possibles might be Pieris, Andromeda, Ericas because of the similarities in soil requirements.

carol23, you are absolutely right! It is more purplish than red, after a second look and this is 100% positive. Thank you for your time!

I had the same thing happen earlier this spring as some of mine just came up. Hadn't really had problems with rabbits before, but I will watch in the future. However, I have had tops broken accidentally off lilies, so I know what to expect. Your lily will live, but will not bloom this year. The rabbit eat all the foliage? If there is still foliage, that will give the plant plenty to gather strength for next year, & may even bloom better because of being gnawed on. I will be curious about your polka lilies. I bought polka about 4 years ago, bright orange with dots. It was a potted blooming plant so I know it was correct with the picture on the label of Polka. The next 2 years it has bloomed a deep maroon with dots. I like it better actually, must be something in my soil that makes the difference though. It really is a nice lily & multiplies like mad.

Sorry, but there are literally tens of Lilies that fit your description. Even with pictures it not easy to ID usually. Try to browse pictures at Holland growers' websites. They have largest selection. For example, this one helped me many times.