Root pruning question - technique and gritty mix

briana_2006

9 years ago

Hello All -

I have in the past root pruned fig trees that were in ~ 11 gallon plastic pots in miracle grow + peat moss + perlite. When I did the root pruning it was a bit past due but the plants came out fine.

I had read about a couple of methods of root pruning -

1) cut ~ 1/4 inch off the bottom and make a 1inch cut in 4 positions from the top to bottom i.e. cut at north, south, east, and west positions

2) remove all the dirt and then trim the roots removing roots that seem to be growing upwards or in a circular path around the base of the tree - removing I believe only about 1/3 of the overall root mass.

When I did the root pruning in the past I did method number 2 - removing all the dirt -- I have a bonsai root pick tool and once all potting mix is removed I sprayed the root mass with a bit of water from a hose to make sure all the potting mix was removed. I also lightly misted the root mass with a spray bottle of water while removing the mix and cutting the roots.

As I said before this method #2 worked well for me with the fig trees.

Questions:

1. It seems to me that although method 2 is much more work --- especially when I have done it I was a bit past due and the root mass was really overgrown -- i.e. roots growing up into the center of the root system --- that it is a better method because more of the root system is addressed and the cut off roots totally removed.

However, am I wrong? Are both methods above equally efficient for producing strong new growth in a (fig) tree?

Question #2:

I would like to soon put a tree in ~ 11 gallon or larger pot (15 or 20 gallon) containing gritty mix. I recall seeing a picture of a bonsai tree Al Tapla had in gritty mix that I believe he had just root pruned or was getting ready to root prune. It seemed like it had a good amount of the gritty mix attached to the root system.

I am just thinking forward to the time when I would have to root prune a fig that is in such a pot of gritty mix. Obviously, the gritty mix is very heavy - I will use a two wheeler to move the pot around.

Should I expect a significant amount of the gritty mix to stick to the root system when I try to remove the plant from the pot? The entire potting mix mass containing miracle grow with a small amount of peat moss and perlite mixed in is removed from the container when I root pruned before.

I am just worried that if a lot of the gritty mix adheres or is not easily removed so that it can fall back into the pot then it will be far too hard to root prune a plant of this size that is in gritty mix because of the weight of the mix - i.e. I will not be able to lift the tree out of the pot if a significant amount of the gritty mix is attached to the root system due to the weight of the gritty mix.

I currently have a number of other plants in gritty mix in much smaller pots -- I have not yet had the need to root prune any of those so I don't have any direct experience root pruning something that has been growing in the gritty mix.

Any thoughts?

Thanks,
Brian

Comments (4)

nil13
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
I think technique 1 is good for correcting root issues when planting container stock in the ground. I use technique 2 when I'm putting the stock back in a container.

The gritty just falls away.
briana_2006
Original Author
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Thanks Nil13 for the response!
Brian
Related Discussions
Another question regarding watering with gritty mix and 511 mix.
Q
Comments (0)
Hi all, Last year, I made some 511 mix using the gritty mix components. I had the gritty mix ingredients readily available but I didn't think I could water every day, so, I used the 511 ratio with the fir bark, granite, and turface thinking that the 5 parts of bark would retain more water. I may not have accomplished my goal, or I may not have the correct watering/fertilizing schedule. I may have may some other mistake, as well. I would appreciate any comments from those more experienced. Thanks in advance to all who have time from re-potting to answer. I use my modified 511 mix for 2 very young citrus, one Meyer Lemon, and one Mexican Lime. These had nearly died off the first winter due to frost as well as having been in overly large containers (halved wine barrels) in potting soil with very little drainage. They responded well to being in the new mix, I also put them in smaller plastic containers about half the size of the wine barrels but these may have been too big as well as far as watering goes. The mop string was moist at the bottom of the container but the mixture may have been dry where the plant roots actually were. Over the summer, however, the leaves started turning yellow. I had been fertilizing with MG 12-4-8 and occasionally with Epsom salt. At the end of the summer, I added a liquid Bloom product for citrus and the leaves responded but no flowers. This winter they have done better. I kept them from frost and have continued with the same water/fertilizer (once a week) and they are both now producing blooms and fruit. Very mild winter here this year. I'm concerned that with the advent of summer conditions, I may not be watering enough or have the proper fertilizer. The plastic containers the citrus are in have a decorative lip which is breaking off from my moving the containers under cover at night, and I'm starting to lose the soil at the top. I'm wondering if it is too late to re-pot now or would it be better to wait until later in the spring? Also, If I could re-pot now, would it be a good idea to use a smaller size container so as to avoid having the top of the pot dry out and the bottom still be moist? My other container plants are blueberry bushes which seem to be doing well in this mix except for one which went into the mix without removing the original soil. (I don't know what I was thinking!) Again, I wonder if I can re pot this one bush and remove the old soil or is it too late for that? With the mild weather conditions, these have been in bloom almost all of Feb. The blueberries were in smaller containers so I think the amount of water they got over the summer was the correct amount. I also used vinegar with the fert. After reading again the idea to use the wood skewers, I think that may be more helpful than the mop string at the bottom. Thanks for any advice. Ande
...See More
Boug leaves dried after bare rooted repot in gritty mix...
Q
Comments (10)
Ohiofem: Thank you for your response. I appreciate the information. I have kept a pretty close eye on it and there are no pests. I have been watering regularly for the last week but as I mentioned in my first post it was clear that there were issues within the first 24hrs. I wasn't sure whether to treat this like I would like other repots and keep it partially shaded. Perhaps it was a poor choice but I opted to take it into full light. Josh: I realize that the gritty mix is effectively nutritionally bare but I had decided not to fertilize immediately after the repot in order to give the boug some recovery time. Now - two weeks on and bare of leaves - it probably would not be a good idea to give any nitrogen. Do you think a transplant fertilizer at this point would be helpful? What you've described with regards to the drainage layer is precisely what I've encountered. I repotted a ficus about 5 days ago and it also is drying unevenly. Considering that the ficus was healthy and its roots were minimally disturbed I opted to pull it and repot it sans pumice drainage layer. We'll see how it fares. Thanks again for your response. Al (tapla): Thanks for the information. I will try the wedge technique in the future. Just a couple of questions: 1) Is the Wedge technique for root reduction solely, or do you use this graduated approach for removing old soil as well (i.e. do you always bare root directly or do you go in segments when dealing with fibrous root systems)? 2) Regarding Watering: my Ficus has a relatively flat root system. The surface is drying quickly and the bottom of the pot stays moist. I am hoping that the removal of the drainage layer will help. When you are dealing with a shallow root system after repot you water more frequently, but does that mean you water less deeply (i.e. to avoid contributing to the slower draining soil at the base of the pot)? Thanks again to everyone who has responded so far. Regards, - JW
...See More
Bare root repot gritty mix concerns
Q
Comments (11)
@Bigmario I think I answered your post about the large pots in another thread. @Mksmith & Redshirt: I hope your trees recover. My experience follows the bell-curve. The largest majority just languish after bare-rooting (not discussing root-pruning here) only drop a few leaves if any, but do not thrive until the next growing season. A minor amount will act like nothing happen and flush out very soon (if appropriate season) and the other end of the spectrum, a minor few will drop many, many leaves and I think it will croak, but it doesn't. It keeps a small set of them and the next growing season does great. It still pains me greatly to watch that happen, though. I'm lucky on my larger trees I've barerooted they were not at the bad end of the curve. The only healthy tree I've lost prior was when I root-pruned at the same time. I also lost two that were destined to die from frozen roots during winter. Unfortunately, I have no way of seeing the pattern (yet) as to which will do well or not. I just finished putting a smaller sized 3yr old Kinnow (that had tons of leaves on it) into an 18gal container with gritty mix and I thought it went beautifully. I saw little to no root loss and was quite proud. As of today, it is still on the decline, having lost over half its leaves. I was ticked and saddened at such an unexpected decline. I thought I'd have to come here and say "I lost my first tree doing a repot". However, semi-good news for me. It turns out the holes in the bottom of my Kinnow container were just slightly too small (used the wrong size drill bit) or the fiberglass insect screen mesh was too fine. A few days ago I was suspicious, b/c the leaves looked exactly like over-watering damage, so I bore it out with larger bit and sure enough, perhaps a pint or two of water came out the bottom. I went around to my other recent repots and found one other with the same problem and same amount of water. That other container was with the 4-1 mix of CHC/peat (recommended by Millet) and it hasn't lost one leaf and looks great (the far end of my bell curve). Interesting...
...See More
Ficus Lyrata repot to gritty mix, sad roots
Q
Comments (5)
I did the same thing last fall with a big sprawling and very sad looking schefflera that had lost most of its leaves, and found the same thing--virtually no fine roots, just thick and mostly woody encircling roots. I did prune almost all the thick roots but left one woody one alone to hold the plant up while I filled the pit with 5:1:1, shaking and tapping the pot to make sure the mix filled in all the books and crannies. Be aware that the plant will sulk longer than if you repotted in the spring, but it will grow a few new leaves in the winter and really liven up in late spring and summer with longer days and more light. A south or southwest facing window will help, and I recommend adding supplemental light in the winter, even if it's just a few 100W bright white (5000-6500k) CFL or LED bulbs in regular fixtures close to the leaves. All my plants, including the repotted scheff, went from practically dormant to getting new leaves after I added the light in late fall.
...See More
Joe1980
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Nil is correct, method 1 is standard for planting into the ground, and method 2 works for pots. However, what should be added to that is that when you root prune, your goal is obviously to reduce the space the roots take up, so eliminating the least useful roots is what you want to do. The larger the root, the less useful it is, being that large roots are more of an anchor, which is great in the ground, but not necessary in a pot. The small feeder roots are what you want, as they do all the work of taking in water and nutrients.

I have a rather large ficus 'alii' that I got free from a plant shop, because it was "dead". I literally grabbed it out of the rolling dump cart on its way outside. It was so root bound that the plastic pot was severely bulged, and it probably couldn't take up water, as there was hardly any soil. Long story short, it is now a beautiful tree, thriving in barkless gritty mix. What I did was grab a pruning saw, and cut out ALL roots larger than about 3/4", clipped any dead branches off, clean the old soil off the roots, fill in the gritty mix, and wait. After a few months it sprang to life, and has only improved from there.

As for upkeep, I repot it every couple of years, as needed. I basically scoop away the loose gritty mix, pull the tree from the pot, and most of the mix will easily shake away from the roots. I remove about 1/4 to 1/3 of the roots, targeting the largest ones. I usually prune out some foliage to maintain a good form too. Better for you to choose which leaves go, rather than let the plant choose. I know I said long story short, so I guess I got a bit carried away. Anywho, the gist of it is to cut out the large anchor roots each time you repot. Good luck, have fun, and enjoy the benefits of a job well done.

Joe
briana_2006
Original Author
9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Thank you Joe for the great information!
I appreciate it!
Brian

Root pruning question - technique and gritty mix

Comments (4)

nil13

briana_2006
Original Author

Related Discussions

Joe1980

briana_2006
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Root pruning question - technique and gritty mix

Comments (4)

nil13

briana_2006Original Author

Related Discussions

Joe1980

briana_2006Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

briana_2006
Original Author

briana_2006
Original Author